Grouted connection with shear keys in monopile - need a second opinion 1

• Sep 16, 2020

• #2

HTURKAK

Structural

Jul 22, 2017

3,371

You could apply a bending moment to your model ..but looking for the maximum nominal radial contact pressure at the top and at the
bottom of the grouted connection will not be reasonable approach.

Consider the joint as a cylindrical tube, the axial force resistance developing will govern..

Simply ,you may transfer the moment to a couple and try to find the bearing stress transfer thru the beads.

What about the beads? Weld bead ?..

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 16, 2020

• Thread starter
• #3

drennon236

Civil/Environmental

Mar 27, 2020

102

NO

Im sorry but could you expand on what you mean? I am not sure I follow, ill try to give my understanding.

- I look at the entire joint as one cylindrical tube and dont consider the contact inbetween the parts. The axial force will be governing, when I apply the moment I should check for the axial force resistance, but how can I know what axial force I am supposed to get from the applied moment, is there an equation?

- Do you mean I should apply moment and see how its transferred to the shear keys or beads? So apply moment and look at what stress develops in the beads?


"What about the beads? Weld bead ?.."

Is there a way for me to use weld beads (shear keys) to confirm my computer my model is correct? Maybe just look at the weight of the cylindrical tube and see if the weight is carried entirely by the weld beads/shear keys?

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 16, 2020

• #4

HTURKAK

Structural

Jul 22, 2017

3,371

In order to see the analogy, consider only axial load is transferred . The axial load will be resisted with bearing of grout and the bearing area will be the horizontal bead surface with grout and the grout will only resist compression stresses.
With this approach, if you limit the bearing stress of the grout, you can calculate the no. of bead rings.

In case of pure moment, if somebody model the moment with a couple applied to grout ring , IMO, acceptable. Say, the dia 50 in. and the moment 1000 kips-in. The couple force C= 1000/ (0.8 *50)=25 kips and arm =40 in. The couple force will be effective for a crescent part say with a length = 3*50/6= 25 in.

You may refine the approach the moment will be resisted with a ring and find the max fiber stress through the lap length.


Your picture implies weld bead. The beads can be weld bead, round bar with fillet welds , flat bar with fillet welds.

P.S. The allowable bearing stress shall be limited 20 psi for service loading and grout strength shall be limited fcu ≤ 16,000 psi

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 16, 2020

• Thread starter
• #5

drennon236

Civil/Environmental

Mar 27, 2020

102

NO

The shear keys look something like this, they go along the entire circumference:

So the axial load will simply be carried by the shear keys, I can measure the load the shear keys are carrying and see if it makes sense (make sure it takes all the self weight and potential axial load).

Would it be possible for you to do a simple drawing of the second part of your explanation with the pure moment applied? It would be very helpful in understanding.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 16, 2020

• #6

Retrograde

Structural

Aug 26, 2015

616

AU

Those equations in your first post, what publication do they come from?

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 17, 2020

• #7

dold

Structural

Aug 19, 2015

624

MT, USA

I can't really comment on the bending aspect of this, but a good analogy for axial load transfer would be something similar to how the deformations on rebar react against the surrounding concrete. For whatever that's worth...

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 17, 2020

• #8

HTURKAK

Structural

Jul 22, 2017

3,371

Dear drennon236 ;

Use the famous bending formula.. f= M/ W ( W section modulus of the circular grout section ) find the max . stress and multiply with grout thick. You will find the force column. Then divide 20 psi and find the bead area required, then divide to bead thick. ( h with your notation ) and find the no. of beads.

For more info. give all the dimensions (pipe dims, thicks, grout thick, bead dims), the applied moment and the software that you use.. good luck...

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 17, 2020

1
• Thread starter
• #9

drennon236

Civil/Environmental

Mar 27, 2020

102

NO

Dear Retrogade: its DNV-OS-J101 - Design of Offshore Wind Turbine Structures - Section 9.2.3.
link below:

https://rules.dnvgl.com/docs/pdf/DNV/codes/docs/2014-05/Os-J101.pdf

Dear HTURKAK:

I use Abaqus CAE, and moment applied can be anything, but lets say -2.08E4 in the y-direction. The loads in this model (moment, concentrated force etc)is applied to the transition piece top, it is applied to a top point which distributes the moment averagely across the top (structural distribution).

Dimensions are shown below.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 17, 2020

• #10

HTURKAK

Structural

Jul 22, 2017

3,371

Dear drennon236 ;

Lets check your dimensions ;
Sleeve geometry = Ds /ts = 9000/80 =112.5 ?? should be less than 80,
Pile geometry = Dp/ tp = 9000/ 97= 93 ?? should be less than 40,
Grout annulus geometry = Dg/tg =9000/70=128 ?? should be less than 45
Shear key shape factor = w /h =80/40=2 O.K.

You provided a nominal moment My= 20400 kN -m , and assume a axial load W = 50000 kN.

The max. shell compression force at transition piece Nc= W/(Pi* D )+ 4*Md /(Pi*D**2) =50000/pi*9.3 +4*20400/pi*9.3**2 =1711+300 = say 2000 kN .

the nominal allowable axial load transfer stress for the grout fba= 0.138 + 0.5 fcu*h/s=´0.138+0.5*40*40/850 =0.95 MPa

No of shear key required= 2000000/1000*40= 50 no's You are expected to provide 50 shear key for transition piece and 50 shear keys for monopile. The shear key spacing could be 300 mm .. in this case, the overlapping length will be 15000 mm.

This is a preliminary calc. based on nominal loads and i did not check for calculation mistakes..

I will suggest you to look API RECOMMENDED PRACTICE 2A-WSD (RP 2A-WSD) Commentary Section C.7.4.4d.

You are free to perform finite element analysis with abaqus but your design should be based on calculations which are verified with tests.

 

Upvote 0 Downvote

• Sep 19, 2020

• #11

HTURKAK

Structural

Jul 22, 2017

3,371

Dear Dear drennon236 ;

This thread regarding the grouted connections of monopiles is not a common thread. When you decide upon your final solution for the analysis model , please share your solution for record and to help younger fellows and keep us involved..

I have written my respond for the preliminary calculation without looking to DNV-OS-J101 - Design of Offshore Wind Turbine Structures - Section 9.2.3.

I just want to remind also , it is polite to answer when you get a respond.



Kind regards..

 

Upvote 0 Downvote