New Laser- Your Opinion Counts!!!

Question

New Laser- Your Opinion Counts!!!

QSF (Industrial)

(OP)

26 Apr 04 11:06

We are presently using a mazak stx510 with a 1500 watt resonator. We are planning on purchasing a new laser with a 5'x10' bed and at least a 3000 watt resonator. We primarily cut only flat sheet metal, so we only need a 2 axis laser. I would like to have your feedback on machines that you have used as far as:
Cost of the machine, frequency of maintenance, cost of consumables, is the software for that particular machine (if purchased with the machine-example: Amada software with Amada laser) user friendly and stable. (We have had quite a bit of trouble with the stability of our code-generating software we are presently using.)
Are you overall satisified with your purchase???

Gary L. Ellis Jr.
Quality Steel Fabrication
Sidney, OH

jmartin931 (Industrial) · Answer 1 · 2004-05-06 03:08:53

Bystronics are very good and easy to work on as are the Cincinnati. Not sure on cost cost comparison.

msandoval (Industrial) · Answer 2 · 2004-05-11 02:13:54

Look at Amada's Gemini 3015 for the smallest footprint for machines in its class as well as their laser software (AlphaCAM).

Fanuc Laser, Control, and drives plus Amada reliability makes this machine one of the best in its class and best of all SUPPORT.

Shop around as well. Trumpf, Bystronics, Cincinnati, Mitsubishi, Mazak. I believe Amada is the Lexus of the industry.

caren (Mechanical) · Answer 3 · 2004-06-03 23:36:19

Hi Gary,

We run a 2kw Mazak Laser, and I for one think it is a very good machine. The software sucks, but I have replaced that with SigmaNest software which I highly recommend and other than that we have had very little trouble with it. It is now close to 12000 hrs and we are just looking now at doing a resonator service. Not Bad.
The backup and service for mazak is not very good, which is a shame because it distacts from an otherwise very good machine.
Maybe have a look at the new Mazak 4Kw and see what you think.

Regards
Dale Lupi.

Come Join Us!

Posting Guidelines

New Laser- Your Opinion Counts!!!