Collector Element Design
Collector Element Design
(OP)
Hi,
I have a question about collector design. I use ENERCALC to generate seismic base shear and force distribution, story shears. But ENERCALC has 2 level and story forces: Fx and Fpx. Should I use Fpx, diaphragm force to design collector elements? I think if I use it the collector diagram won't balance out to 0 right? also what is the use of Fpx? I read ASCE but it's not clearly explained.
Thanks
I have a question about collector design. I use ENERCALC to generate seismic base shear and force distribution, story shears. But ENERCALC has 2 level and story forces: Fx and Fpx. Should I use Fpx, diaphragm force to design collector elements? I think if I use it the collector diagram won't balance out to 0 right? also what is the use of Fpx? I read ASCE but it's not clearly explained.
Thanks
RE: Collector Element Design
So when constructing the collector force diagram what I do is apply the amplified load and then I scale the shear wall forces by the same amount which act as reactions on the collector. This way the diagram does balance out to zero where needed.
RE: Collector Element Design
RE: Collector Element Design
For example in a single story building, equation 12.10-1 of ASCE 7-16 ends up being Fx * Wr / Wr = Fx.
Definitely don't go less than Fx for collector design. And don't forget to check Fpx min = 0.2SdsIeWpx.
RE: Collector Element Design
RE: Collector Element Design
But even so the story shear isn't really relevant to diaphragm design unless you have transfer forces in the diaphrams due to discontinuities. Think about the load path, the diaphragm doesn't experience cumulative forces like the shear walls do (sans discontinuities).
Without transfer forces you need only compare Fx with Fpx. Furthermore the reaction on your collectors per floor is only based on the forces generated at that floor level.
The reason we need Fpx is because the vertical distribution of forces from the ELF procedure is based on a first mode displacement. In reality the building will have mass participation in higher modes as well. These higher modes would make less story shear and overturning in the MLFRS but higher diaphragm inertial forces. Hence the need to amplify the diaphragm force as you go down the building (Fpx >= Fx)
RE: Collector Element Design
RE: Collector Element Design
What I usually do is calculate Fx, then Fpx for each level. Then find the ratio Fpx/Fx for each level. Now when you go to a collector line you multiply the Fx level forces in that line by the ratio, the result are the reactions on the collector.
Clear as mud ?
RE: Collector Element Design
RE: Collector Element Design