×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

(OP)
Which gate valve is better for 125 psig steam, cast steel or iron?  Why?

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

Most piping specifications avoid cast iron for pressure applications.  Steel is better because cast iron cracks with lower stress.  A crack in a 125 psig steam could cause injury or kill people.  The lost downtime is expensive.  The installation labor is not much different.

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

What is the safety valve setting? There are lots of steam systems running at 125#, but the safety valves lift at 150#. Very often, these systems are filled with 125# cast iron valves & strainers - because they're cheaper than cast steel. However, they don't meet code. Even if the safety valves lift at 125, unless the raised faces are removed from the flanges on the piping, they STILL don't meet code.

Check out www.kirsner.org for some shots of failed 125 cast iron components - usually involving fatalities.

I've worked with steam for 30 years, and I absolutely LOATHE 125 cast iron valves & fittings - even where permitted by code.

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

(OP)
So is it just a matter of pressure rating, or is there any other reason for choosing one over the other?  In my case you're right, the PRV lifts at 130 psig.  I was going to use a 250# or 300# valve anyway, which is why I asked which is better.  Both are well above my relief valve setting.  

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

Don't ignore ductile or malleable irons. They are ductile like steel but are cheaper.

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

You are correct, for 125# steam it is a good idea to use either 250# cast iron or 300# steel.  The main difference is that cast iron is much more brittle than steel.

So, if you drop a cast iron valve it may crack but not a steel.

My customers prefer also steel in steam service because of the chance of water hammer.  Large banging in the pipes could crack the flange of cast iron and not steel.

In refineries and chemical plants they often do not allow cast iron, but for another reason. If there is a fire, the cast iron tensile strength breaks down at a lower temperature than that of steel.

Ductile Iron is more malleable than cast iron, has many of the same properties of steel at a reduced cost.  It is a great material!

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

A gate valve for steam is the last thing I look into. I used globe, piston, diaphragm and even ball valves successfully but never a gate. Do you guys have any exploded views or pictures of the gate valves you are speaking?

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

Not sure what's wrong with gate valves for low pressure steam?  I have seen many OS&Y RF #150 cast steel valves used in low pressure steam systems.

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

Are they for control or shut off? Not that it's anything wrong but my experience has been pretty bad. Particularly, the ones that were to bypass a pressure regulating stations.

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

I assumed they are for shut off.  A gate valve is a poor choice for a throttling valve.  

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

I would agree that in general a gate valve is not the best for steam as it likely will erode on the bottom of the gate.

Gate valves do not throttle well like globes. However, gates do offer large Cv's for the size and if used for shut-off only  and maintained full open for flowing they may be appropriate. However, do look at the design to assure the gate is out of the flow stream and talk to the manufacturer.

Further, regardless what you select the valve should be for steam service in addition to having the T & P capabilities.

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

The materials gray cast iron and later developed ductile cast iron have of course been mentioned on this thread (along with some references with regard to same).  Gray cast iron is of course generally a quite venerable construction material that has been around for hundreds of years in piping, valves, and other applications.    
However, while I don’t think the particular all ductile iron valves pictured should be used for steam applications you may nevertheless be interested in the general material-related features and special testing of some gate valves contained in the four minutes or so video "Ductile versus Gray Presentation" near the bottom of the page http://www.acipco.com/afc/videos.cfm under  the heading “Product Presentation Files”.  This video provides some more information/clues as to how/why gray cast iron valves might be more easily overloaded or broken in handling, installation, and or service events than the much stronger/tougher ductile material, and probably also why some manufacturers and users have opted instead for ductile iron constructions.    

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

rconner:

That is a nice video.

BronYrAur:

One more bit of information. Jordan Valve makes a sliding gate valve specifically for steam service. It is available in DI, Steel and other materials. You might look at it for your application.
(I don't work there but I did at one time.)

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: Cast Steel or Iron Gate Valves?

steam has its own requirements.  There are valves specifically manufactured for steam service.  Always use a steam valve in steam service.  Also, I am a great believer in calling the manufacturer and getting their expertise.  You would be surprised how helpful the sales engineer can be when trying to learn about different products.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login


Resources

White Paper – Choosing the Right Spring Loaded Connector
In today’s cost-sensitive world, designers are often driven to specify the lowest cost solution for every aspect of their designs to ensure that their solution is competitively priced and their company remains profitable. However, specifying a low-cost, low-quality connector solution can result in premature failure, considerable re-work costs and damage to reputations. Download Now
eBook – Own the Lifecycle: Sustainable Business Transformation
Increasingly, product and services companies are seeking more information and control in the operational lifecycle of their products, including service and use. Better information about the operational lifecycle, and the ability to use that information, requires more than just unstructured data flowing back from products in the field. Download Now

Close Box

Join Eng-Tips® Today!

Join your peers on the Internet's largest technical engineering professional community.
It's easy to join and it's free.

Here's Why Members Love Eng-Tips Forums:

Register now while it's still free!

Already a member? Close this window and log in.

Join Us             Close