Bug in Excel Trend Lines
Bug in Excel Trend Lines
(OP)
Has anybody encountered a bug in the trend lines which Excel generates from regression? The equation of the trend line did not give me the expected values. I was working on exponential and polynomial type of lines. I had to adjust the co-efficients of the equations to get somewhat better results.
Thanks.
Samiran
Thanks.
Samiran
RE: Bug in Excel Trend Lines
The more data points you have, the more the trendline (and its equation) will represent the data you have, especially if your data fits a polonomial expression.
I've had the same experience. I'll have a bunch of data that the trendline represents really well in the middle, but is in >90% error on either end point of the data.
If you are trying to fit an equation to data so you can calculate "y" by entering "x" into a cell in excel, it may be helpful to split your data into sections and fit trendlines to each section instead of trying to get one equation to fit the entire data range.
Example:
for data of y = 1-200, x = 30-600
Instead of entering all data from y=1 (x=30) to y=200 (x=600), enter y=1 to y=100 in one chart and y=101 to y=200 in another chart and fit trendlines to each graph.
Good luck!
jproj
RE: Bug in Excel Trend Lines
The idea you've suggested is actually not bad - to have diff trend line s for diff sets of data. This only shows one should always try to query results before walking away happily with the solution offered by any readymade tool.
Thanks again.
Samiran
RE: Bug in Excel Trend Lines
Ailsa
RE: Bug in Excel Trend Lines
RE: Bug in Excel Trend Lines