EngineerofSteel
Structural
- May 18, 2005
- 156
I have an architect friend who sends me projects.
He drew a commercial building, 2-story, 115'x22'8".
The north and east walls are uninterrupted CMU. The south and west walls are light-frame shear walls- with many windows.
I don't like the design.
Here are my concerns. Please comment- I would like to have input on efficient design for this project and on non-typical checks I should perform.
* The wood will deflect more than the CMU. How will this affect: torsion; wood:CMU connections; load distribution to walls (I expect more load will transfer to more rigid CMU walls than to wood walls.)
* If I design a rigid connection at the CMU side, and a simple support at the wood side, what concerns will I have?
I have designed all CMU and CMU+steel and all-wood, but not wood +CMU on the same story.
Thanks---
He drew a commercial building, 2-story, 115'x22'8".
The north and east walls are uninterrupted CMU. The south and west walls are light-frame shear walls- with many windows.
I don't like the design.
Here are my concerns. Please comment- I would like to have input on efficient design for this project and on non-typical checks I should perform.
* The wood will deflect more than the CMU. How will this affect: torsion; wood:CMU connections; load distribution to walls (I expect more load will transfer to more rigid CMU walls than to wood walls.)
* If I design a rigid connection at the CMU side, and a simple support at the wood side, what concerns will I have?
I have designed all CMU and CMU+steel and all-wood, but not wood +CMU on the same story.
Thanks---