Why are structural engineers asking for free software? I am really perplexed by this often appearing questions in this forum. Few questions and I really do not want to step on any ones toe in my feedback:
1. Even if one finds free software, how do you ensure its accuracy and methodology?
2. What is wrong with doing things long hand?
3. Are new and young engineers are out of touch with reality when it comes to performing hand calculations?
4. Does anyone in this forum want to use a structure designed by an engineer who performed his calculations on free software he found on the Internet and he had no clue how the software functions and what codes it uses?
Young engineers should motivate themselves to do calculations manually and then may be graduate to writing their own programs or buying a bona-fide and tested preprograms. Even at that, they must be trained on how to utilize the software.
I often wonder how many young structural engineers can perform moment distribution manually!
Just to prove my point, I came across an engineer who was using STAAD to design a concrete beam using lateral loads. Well, guess what? STAAD does not design beams for weak axis bending. If you do not believe me, check their technical manuals!!
I hope I got my point across.
Regards,
Lutfi