A potential problem with many thread length-of-engagement "rules of thumb" is that they are typically based on an assumption that the mating internal and external threads are made from materials of approximately the same strength level.
You can calculate the length of engagement required to prevent shear or "stripping" of the lower strength internal aluminum thread at the anticipated design load. This calculation is based on the geometric shear area of the internal thread at minimum material condition (equal to the area of that thread which is intersected by a cylinder with a diameter equal to the minimum major diameter of the mating external thread over the length of engagement) and shear strength of the parent thread material. An excellent source of formulas, information and examples for performing these (and other) thread strength calculations are found in Appendix B of FED-STD-H28/2B -- available for free at
These formulas are relatively simple, accurate and readily lend themselves to entry and reuse in a spreadsheet. If you don’t know the shear strength of your materials, two possible sources of free online information are MatWeb (usually “typical” values) at
or in MIL-HDBK-5 (usually statistically adjusted values to a given confidence level) at
Alternately, you wish to use an applicable material specification “minimum guaranteed” value.
As suggested by a previous poster, externally threaded inserts in “low strength” materials will not only prevent thread damage resulting from repeated reuse but will also increase the thread shear load in your aluminum material for a given bolt diameter/thread (insert internal diameter/thread) and length of engagement due to the greater thread shear area provided by the greater external insert thread shear area. Conversely, for a given bolt diameter/thread, they permit a shorter length of engagement in the aluminum material to achieve a given strength level. Well designed inserts for use in aluminum are typically designed with external thread lengths (insert heights) long enough to develop sufficient “pull out” resistance to ensure tensile failure of a high strength bolt fully engaged with the internal insert thread. For threads that are frequently disassembled , it is a good practice to increase the calculated length of engagement to allow for expected wear of the flanks of the threads (and the resulting decrease in tensile capability) over the useful life of the components -- another good reason to use threaded inserts in aluminum for high reuse threads.