I was trained on PRO/E. Even the tutors didn't have a good grasp of the software. I later used SolidWorks - it's terrible. I've used Inventor - it's terrible. I've used FreeCAD - I didn't stick around long enough to learn how terrible it actually is. Now, I'm using Solid Edge - it's beyond terrible.
The purpose of this thread is two-fold: to complain about the diabolical standard of available general mechanical design software; and to ask is there is actually any that is not terrible.
Solid Edge is the current software that is torturing me. I gave-up on the other programs I mentioned. I will not be using Solid Edge again after I have finished my current project. It is inefficient, it is counter-intuitive; its graphical presentation (of the model being made) is utterly deplorable (it hides errors), and it lacks basic functionality. Things that should be easy and simple are either hopelessly inefficient (requiring esoteric knowledge and a dozen steps where one obvious step would have done), or do not exist.
At this point, I know what you are thinking: that I simply do not know how to use this program properly. Yes, you are right. But then, who does? I'll tell you who does: people trained following a lengthy and involved period of indoctrination (yes, indoctrination), and whom use the software frequently - every day - know - eventually - how to use it without having a mental breakdown each time. Me? I have not had specific training for it (only tuition for PRO/E), and I do not use it every day. What chance do I have? None! Well, maybe if I hired a tutor for a few £thousand and put aside a couple of hours a day to keep practising it, like I put aside time to exercise, use the toilet, eat, and generally respire.
The software is shamefully bad to the point that I can barely comprehend that it was not made the way it is with deliberate intent. Are real-life products actually designed using this garbage software that costs so much money? I am at a loss. I don't think there is any alternative to it. All the CAD software I've used works in very similar ways - just some very bad and others extremely bad. There is nothing good out there, or is there? Is there anything I don't know about? I Google for lists of this software, but nothing looks promising out of returned options I am yet to try (because it's either browser-based or made by the same companies that made the junk I've already used).
Photoshop. This is software I also do not use every day but it is far more intuitive than Solid Edge, and I do not get stuck with Photoshop as I do with SE. Why can't SE be more like PS with respect to basic operation? CAD programmers need to study Photoshop and learn how software can be intuitive and friendly to use.
Solid Edge is beyond frustrating. I actually feel hatred towards the company and people that made it. I wish they hadn't bothered. They have cost me months of my life with their awful, horribly made garbage software. I spit on them.
The purpose of this thread is two-fold: to complain about the diabolical standard of available general mechanical design software; and to ask is there is actually any that is not terrible.
Solid Edge is the current software that is torturing me. I gave-up on the other programs I mentioned. I will not be using Solid Edge again after I have finished my current project. It is inefficient, it is counter-intuitive; its graphical presentation (of the model being made) is utterly deplorable (it hides errors), and it lacks basic functionality. Things that should be easy and simple are either hopelessly inefficient (requiring esoteric knowledge and a dozen steps where one obvious step would have done), or do not exist.
At this point, I know what you are thinking: that I simply do not know how to use this program properly. Yes, you are right. But then, who does? I'll tell you who does: people trained following a lengthy and involved period of indoctrination (yes, indoctrination), and whom use the software frequently - every day - know - eventually - how to use it without having a mental breakdown each time. Me? I have not had specific training for it (only tuition for PRO/E), and I do not use it every day. What chance do I have? None! Well, maybe if I hired a tutor for a few £thousand and put aside a couple of hours a day to keep practising it, like I put aside time to exercise, use the toilet, eat, and generally respire.
The software is shamefully bad to the point that I can barely comprehend that it was not made the way it is with deliberate intent. Are real-life products actually designed using this garbage software that costs so much money? I am at a loss. I don't think there is any alternative to it. All the CAD software I've used works in very similar ways - just some very bad and others extremely bad. There is nothing good out there, or is there? Is there anything I don't know about? I Google for lists of this software, but nothing looks promising out of returned options I am yet to try (because it's either browser-based or made by the same companies that made the junk I've already used).
Photoshop. This is software I also do not use every day but it is far more intuitive than Solid Edge, and I do not get stuck with Photoshop as I do with SE. Why can't SE be more like PS with respect to basic operation? CAD programmers need to study Photoshop and learn how software can be intuitive and friendly to use.
Solid Edge is beyond frustrating. I actually feel hatred towards the company and people that made it. I wish they hadn't bothered. They have cost me months of my life with their awful, horribly made garbage software. I spit on them.
