It's been a while since I have read 6A, but I think that if you take test specimens from the actual product (as opposed to from a QTC), they must come from 1/4 T of the thickest section of the product and the specimens from all tests (tensile, impact, and hardness) must come from actual product. In addition, if you have a failed test result, there are specific retest procedures you must follow to qualify the lot, you can't just ignore the test results and keep testing until you find results you like.
Get a copy of the standard and read up on the requirements, I am pretty sure it tells you exactly what needs to be done (probably re-heat treating the lot).
rp