The "Trash" Ed mentions is typically sulfur. The sulfur content is about five times higher than the upper limit (to allow for ease of welding)for most steels. The sulfur is a low melting point constituent meaning that it is still in the liquid state long after the surrounding metal has solidified. Much of it gets rejected to the center line of the weld bead (solute rejection), resulting in a longitudinal center line crack once the weld cools. Sulfur solidifies around 235 degrees F if I remember correctly and it doesn't easily alloy with most metals, so it is rejected along the grain boundaries during the manufacturing of the "Free Machining" steel. The presence of the sulfur makes machining easier and it causes the chips to be small rather than one long ribbon. This makes disposal easier for the shop trying to machine a shaft as an example. The sulfur plays havoc when it comes to attempting to weld.
You can try to select a filler metal with a manganese content of about ten times the sulfur content. The manganese will combine with the sulfur, thereby taking it out of solution as a spherical nodule and help to mitigate the potential for cracking. Use stringer beads at low amperage and you might stand a chance of success.
Best regards - Al