sap2000,gtstrudl,staad which should I choose?

Question

sap2000,gtstrudl,staad which should I choose?

Roadmanpd (Civil/Environmental)

(OP)

1 Oct 03 08:19

   Our company want to buy a copy of structural analysis program,which is better? GTSTRUDL? sap2000 or staad?

   What about the price,function,and support?

   Thanks in advance.

fleisher (Structural) · Answer 1 · 2003-10-09 02:21:02

What are u planning on doing? Strudl is outdated. SAP and STAAD are each good. STAAD is more robust and user-friendly IMO.

ElmerTheFudd (Structural) · Answer 2 · 2003-11-01 16:05:19

It depends on what you want to do.  STAAD is cheaper, and geared more towards buildings.  SAP is a much better product for bridges, seismic, nonlinear.

I use both products.  I disagree with fleisher, in that STAAD has given me more suspicious results, and crashed more often than SAP.

The big user difference between the two is the way input files are stored.  STAAD is a text file, which offers much comfort to those used to working in text files and commenting text files.  SAP by default stores the input file in a database.  To edit you must either use Excel, Access, or the SAP program.

Come Join Us!

Posting Guidelines

sap2000,gtstrudl,staad which should I choose?