ASCE 7 versus AWWA D100 seismic loads

breaks · Mar 28, 2001

Calculations I'm reviewing require seismic loads to be calculated using AWWA D100 (for elevated water tanks). The contractor has provided seismic loads using ASCE 7.

Does anyone know if ASCE 7 is more conservative than AWWA D100? I'm a little curious about how the 2 standards compare even though I'm probably going to have to specify the loads be re-done anyway. Any help would be appreciated.

Qshake · Mar 29, 2001

I'm not familiar with the AWWA codes for seismic design but would definitely return the calcs stamped rejected, resubmit per the specifications.

Ron · Mar 29, 2001

Agree with Qshake. Don't take on the delegated liability.

breaks · Mar 29, 2001

Thanks for the input, Ron & Qshake! I agree with your assessment. If I come up with any interesting comparisons between the 2 codes, I'll let you know.

Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

ASCE 7 versus AWWA D100 seismic loads

breaks

Structural

Qshake

Structural

Ron

Structural

breaks

Structural

Similar threads

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor