Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
(OP)
I'm wondering how to test for the effective angle of friction for coarse-grained engineered fill materials. Large shear-box tests are 300mm x 300mm, with a maximum allowable particle size of 37.5mm. I am utilising a high-friction fill (Class 6P, as per Series 600 MCHW)in a design with a phi' value of 45. I am wondering how realistically I can validate this. My experience with high friction fill is that it usually involves very coarse-grained material.
The grading requirements for a Class 6P fill material shows that 100% needs to pass a 75mm sieve, so there could be a lot of material greater than 37.5mm (material that would have to be discounted from a large shear-box).
Does anyone have experience in validating the effective angle of friction of very-coarse grained soils? I can only think of utilising the angle of repose.
The grading requirements for a Class 6P fill material shows that 100% needs to pass a 75mm sieve, so there could be a lot of material greater than 37.5mm (material that would have to be discounted from a large shear-box).
Does anyone have experience in validating the effective angle of friction of very-coarse grained soils? I can only think of utilising the angle of repose.
RE: Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
1. You could build or find someone with a bigger shear box; really big shear boxes or triaxial apparatus are occasionally referenced in the literature so I'm sure this is possible
2. You could use one of the many techniques for scaling the gradation curve down, all of which have limitations
3. You could try and build a large-scale field tilt test like reference in Barton Kjaernsli (Shear strength of rockfill), with the limitation that the normal stress will be very limited and so you are likely to end up with a quite high friction angle at low stress (angles up to 60-70 degrees are reported in the literature)
4. Yes, there is angle of repose, but angle of repose is dominated by 3D edge effects and possibly suction effects
5. Maybe some kind of in-situ direct shear test (not a tilt test) would be possible? Like, you dig out around a block of the placed material in the field and build a field appartus
The below links might help. I'd suggest looking for case histories / literature review for rockfill dams since I think that's one of the fields where this is been done and documented.
https://www.ecsmge-2019.com/uploads/2/1/7/9/217908...
https://www.issmge.org/uploads/publications/1/32/1...
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298425776...
RE: Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
Check the following paper: Soil improvement with vibrated stone columns — influence of pressure level and relative
density on friction angle (Wher 2008)
Although it is for stone columns, friction angles for rounded , smaller (2-32mm dia)river gravels have shone friction angles above 50 deg. For the type of material you are using, a larger, more angular aggregate, a design phi of 45 deg is conservative.
RE: Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
RE: Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
They published results from large triaxial machines.
RE: Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)
RE: Testing of angle of friction on very coarse-grained aggregates (UK)