×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)
12

Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

(OP)
Hi All,

if you can help us to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Motor specification:
- have 2 capacitors (starting 40uF 240V) & (RUNNING 50uF 400V)
- 1.85 Kw
- 1385 rpm
- application for sea water high pressure piston pump

WHAT IS THE EQUATION?
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Step 1: Increase the 60 Hz voltage to 264 Volts, 60 Hz. (note 1)
Step 2: Decrease the run Capacitor to about 40uF to 45uF.
Note 1; In many places, the standard 60 Hz voltage is 240 Volts.
A 240V:24V lighting transformer reconnected as an auto-transformer will deliver 264 Volts.
In the event that your voltage is 220 Volts;
A 240V:48V lighting transformer connected as an auto-transformer will deliver 264 Volts.
Note 2; For a 240 Volt supply, the transformer should be about 500 VA or greater.
for a 220 Volt supply, the transformer should be about 750 VA or greater.
The pump will run faster.
You cannot rewind for the same speed at 60 Hz.
The equations depend on the Volts per Hertz ratio.
For your motor the V/H ratio is 220/50 = 44 V/Hz.
At 60 Hz, 60Hz x 44 = 264 Volts required.
At 60 Hz, 1385 RPM x (60Hz/50Hz) = 1662 RPM

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

2
Nsalhiah,

Why bother?

What are you trying to do here?

Pump spins faster means more power needed from the motor.

Rewinding doesn't seem to make much sense compared to buying something designed for the voltage and frequency you have.

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

nsalhieh (Industrial)(OP)19 Nov 23 13:59
" if you can help us to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)....WHAT IS THE EQUATION?'
1. One of the very important factors is the speed, a pump at 1385rpm @ 50Hz will be running 1662 rpm @ 60Hz. The power (1.85kW @ 50Hz) will be increased to (> 1.85 kW @ 60Hz), with increase in volume. Check with the pump OEM the new kW @ 1662rpm. If 1385rpm output volume is fine, you may have to regulate the valve, as you are unable to control the new speed (@1662rpm).
2. Consider the learned advice by Mr. LittleInch.
Che Kuan Yau (Singapore)

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote:

Pump spins faster means more power needed from the motor.
At the proper voltage on 60 Hz, the motor will develop more power.

Quote:

Rewinding doesn't seem to make much sense compared to buying something designed for the voltage and frequency you have.
Compare the price of a transformer versus the price of a new motor (and possibly an integral pump.)

Quote:

If 1385rpm output volume is fine, you may have to regulate the valve, as you are unable to control the new speed (@1662rpm).
Quite possibly, but you should not attempt to throttle the flow of a positive displacement pump.
Net discharge may be controlled by bypassing some of the flow back to the suction side of the pump or back to the sea.
Your regulating valve will be in the bypass line.
Typical costs for voltage change for small motors.
Highest cost: Rewind.
High cost: Replacement motor.
Lowest cost: Auto-transformer.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

You can most likely run it as it is at 60 Hz if it meets the connected load demand at that increased speed.

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

"...Note 2; For a 240 Volt supply, the transformer should be about 500 VA or greater. for a 220 Volt supply, the transformer should be about 750 VA or greater...."
1. The motor running at 1385rpm (50Hz) is rated 1.85kW. At 1663rpm (60Hz) will be >1.85kW.
2. How can a transformer rated 240V about 500 VA or greater, or 220V about 750VA or greater; which is <1/3 or <1/2 of motor (>1.85kW at 60Hz) be suitable for the job?

Che Kuan Yau (Singapore)

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

(OP)
thank you all for the answers

actually, we run it as its and we got over heat and the measured temperature at the outside cover of motor reached to 105c within 30 min of running so we stop at the that point. the problem with existing situation is that the motor will get damage and this is why we are thinking to rewind according to supplied power that is now 220v 60hz supplied from auto transformer getting main feed power 450v 60htz out of generator on ship

we need the rewinding equation to make sure rewind the motor again to get red of the over heat problem

Note: our RO system have automatic pressure regulating valve at reject line this is why the system will run at constant desired pressure regardless of rpm.

we need the rewinding equation for the motor at 220v and 60 hz

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Post your 220 V, 50 Hz and 220 V, 60 Hz load currents first.

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Well at 20% more power, plus higher amps as the V/htz ratio is lower I'm not surprised.

But first check out what the pump is doing. Flowrate is fixed but what's the pressure compared to the data sheet?

Buy a new motor properly specced for 220V 60Htz

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (Mr Che)

2. How can a transformer rated 240V about 500 VA or greater, or 220V about 750VA or greater; which is <1/3 or <1/2 of motor (>1.85kW at 60Hz) be suitable for the job?
Auto-transformers 101.
With a 120:48 Volt auto-transformer Boosting a 10 Amp motor current, only the 24 Volt winding sees the ten Amp motor current.
10 Amps times 48 Volts = 480 VA.
But the 10 Amps was a guesstimate. At 1385 RPM your slip is 115 RPM.
115 RPM is a relatively high slip and high slip motors tend to have more losses, so a typical current estimate tends to be low.
Thus I opted to recommend transformers a little on the high side.
This formula is for step-up applications only.
For step down applications, the transformer primary current must be added to the secondary current to determine VA rating.
Dropping from 450 Volts to 264 Volts will be extremely difficult to do with standard transformer voltages.
But don't panic; 450 Volts line to line will have a line to neutral voltage of 260 Volts.
Capacitors may be a problem.
If the run capacitor is carrying part of the motor current, it may be causing part of the overheating.
Typically, the run capacitor shifts the phase angle of the current applied to the start winding so that the start winding may assist the main winding by supplying added torque.
With a higher frequency, the capacitive reactance will be lower and this may be causing the start winding to take a disproportionate share of the load.
The solution; A lessor rated run capacitor.

Given the actual motor current, for auto-transformer step up I use the equation:
Motor current x Transformer secondary voltage = VA transformer capacity.
10 Amps x 48 Volts boost = 480 VA.
Note: If 10 Amps is the actual motor current, I would use a 500 VA transformer.
Given that the 10 Amps is a guesstimate, I recommended the next larger size transformer eg: 750 VA.
By the way, over the years I have several times done successful 50/60 Hz and 60/50 Hz conversions.
I have converted 50 Hz motors imported into Canada's 60 Hz grid and I have converted 60 Hz motors exported to 50 Hz grids.

Quote:

Note: our RO system have automatic pressure regulating valve at reject line this is why the system will run at constant desired pressure regardless of rpm.
It may be well to check the actual pressure if this has not already been done.
The increased flow may be too much for the pressure regulator and the actual pressure may be higher than anticipated.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

nsalhieh,

There are some important factor to consider due to incresing the RPM will increase the demanded power from pumps applications up to 1.7 tiems due to affinity laws thus even if you can redesign the winding from 50 Hz to 60 Hz you should trim the pump impeller. However, some of this single-phase motors are equipped with centrifugal switchs if this is the case the change to 60 Hz is not advisable because the centrifugal swith is already setted for the original RPM and is not designed to operate proper at 1.2 the speed thus if the start winding can not disconnec the winding will smoke up.

There are a couple of alternatives here:

1. Verify the application requirements and replace the actual motor with the proper single-motor motor at 60 Hz as Littleinch recommend.
2. Replace the actual motor with a three-phase motor of about 2 times the actual rating, connecting the three phase windng with an steinmetz coinnection;you should calculate a capacitor. See links below
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/63144
https://www.mig-welding.co.uk/forum/threads/steinm...

Best Regards

Petronila

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

There is a member here, zlatkodo, who frequently posts or responds to motor winding techniques, hopefully they see this thread. But if not, here is what I think is their website, where they show some links to on-line calculators.
https://winding.wixsite.com/design

Still, I agree that unless this motor / pump is so specialized that the motor cannot be exchanged, you will likely spend a LOT more money trying to rewind it than you would just buying a new motor with the correct voltage configuration.


" We are all here on earth to help others; what on earth the others are here for I don't know." -- W. H. Auden

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote:

There are some important factor to consider due to incresing the RPM will increase the demanded power from pumps applications up to 1.7 tiems due to affinity laws thus even if you can redesign the winding from 50 Hz to 60 Hz you should trim the pump impeller. However, some of this single-phase motors are equipped with centrifugal switchs if this is the case the change to 60 Hz is not advisable because the centrifugal swith is already setted for the original RPM and is not designed to operate proper at 1.2 the speed thus if the start winding can not disconnec the winding will smoke up.
"There are some important factor to consider due to incresing the RPM will increase the demanded power from pumps applications up to 1.7 tiems due to affinity laws"
The laws that you cite do not apply to a positive displacement pump.
"you should trim the pump impeller" No impellor in a PD pump.
"not advisable because the centrifugal swith is already setted for the original RPM and is not designed to operate proper at 1.2 the speed"
The centrifugal switch will open. The switch does not care what the terminal speed is, It opens when the rotor is turning fast enough for the main winding to generate torque.

It is so much easier to supply the correct voltage than to rewind to accomodate a small change in optimum voltage.
50 Hz motor speeds are based on base speeds of 3000R PM, 1500 RPM, 1000 RPM, 750 RPM.
1385 RPM = base speed 1500 RPM minus 115 RPM slip.
60 Hz motor speeds are based on base speeds of 3600 RPM, 1800 RPM, 1200 RPM, 900 RPM.
REWINDING CANNOT CHANGE THAT.
IF THE FREQUENCY IS INCREASED THE VOLTAGE MUST BE INCREASED IN THE SAME RATIO.
TRY THE CORRECT VOLTAGE FIRST.
The motor is working but is overheating? That is a symptom of low voltage. Try the correct voltage.
The capacitors will draw more current on 60 Hz. You may have to reduce the capacity of the capacitors.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Waross, this is a ship where clearly the supply is 220V 60 htz. I don't think the OP want to add a special tx just for this pump.

He or she clearly just picked up an RO unit from shore and plugged it in not fully realising what would happen going 50 to 60 htz, but the same voltage.

Messing about with convertors or txs etc is just more expense and given the motor is probably cooked by now, just replace it .

Remember - More details = better answers
Also: If you get a response it's polite to respond to it.

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Waross

The problem with the centrifugal switch is real and it is a factor. You can not grant the Centrifugal Switch will works proper for the new speed. Adding a boost transformer is more expensive beceause you will need to size the transformer at leat 3 times the power of the motor and if this is a ship you may not have space for installing new equipment including the controls also the transformer is not standard and needs to be custom made. The user should wait long time instead new motors are easy available.

Just replacing the motor seems is a good option.

Petronila

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (LittleInch)

Waross, this is a ship where clearly the supply is 220V 60 htz. I don't think the OP want to add a special tx just for this pump.
He or she clearly just picked up an RO unit from shore and plugged it in not fully realising what would happen going 50 to 60 htz, but the same voltage.
Do yourself a favour and read the previous posts.
According to one of the posts that you neglected to read:
" 450v 60htz out of generator on ship"
There is already an auto-transformer transformer installed to supply 220 Volts.
The motor wants 264 Volts according to the Volts-per-Hertz law.
The line to neutral voltage of a 450 Volt generator is 260 Volts.
260 Volts to a 264 Volt motor is well within tolerance.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

The ship's generator at 450 volts is most likely an ungrounded system without a neutral. It's possibly delta wired.

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (petronila)

The problem with the centrifugal switch is real and it is a factor. You can not grant the Centrifugal Switch will works proper for the new speed.
The centrifugal switch typically operates at a few hundred RPM. A 1385 RPM motor, a 1685 RPM motor and a 3500 RPM motor will all turn fast enough to properly operate the centrifugal switch.

Quote (petronila)

Adding a boost transformer is more expensive because you will need to size the transformer at leaat 3 times the power of the motor
Stick to what you know.
The standard industrial voltage in Canada is 600 Volts. We get a lot of 480 Volt equipment from the US.
Some industrial plants opt to install their own transformers and use 480 Volts, but the have to accommodate 600 Volt motors (Actually 575 Volt rated motors are used on 600 Volt systems.
Using auto-transformers to covert between 480 Volts and 600 Volts is a frequent chore in Canada.
The KVA rating of the boost transformers is typically 5/16 of the motor KVA dropping to 480 and 1/4 of the motor KVA boosting to 600 Volts.
For a conventional transformer supplying a motor, a transformer KVA of 125% of the motor KVA is common.
That said, I have seen transformers sized at 300%.
It was in the third world where kickbacks were common.
All of the suppliers offered a nice, under the table, rebate to any electrician bringing in a transformer order.
The worst case that I encountered was a 150 KVA transformer bank to supply a 17 KVA load.
So, yes, in some areas 300% transformer capacity is justified.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (TugBoatEng)

The ship's generator at 450 volts is most likely an ungrounded system without a neutral. It's possibly delta wired.
Fair comment, Tug.
I considered that and decided not to mention it unless the OP mentioned it.
An artificial neutral (grounded or floating) is not hard to field fabricate.
Three lighting transformers connected in wye:delta will develop the artificial neutral.
The primary voltage must be above 260 Volts and the secondary (delta) voltage does not matter.
I won't guesstimate sizes until the OP reports the motor current.
In any event less than 1000 KVA.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

It's a 2 horsepower motor.

OP needs to take a few steps back. A 2 hp TEFC 3 phase motor is less than $1000 USD and will be much more reliable. If the system can handle the extra speed, fine. If not install a VFD. 2 horsepower VFDs are cheap. If the current system has a single phase contactor the 2 hp VFD will allow this to work without modification to the system. At this point in time VFDs and contactors cost the same (I buy NEMA contactors as I have found IEC contactors unreliable with low quality marine grade power).

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

I am with tugboat. 3-ph, 4 pole, 60 Hz off-the shelf motor matching the driven load is the simplest eliminating the centrifugal switch, capacitors etc. which are additional failure points.

High time OP responded. Otherwise, we are wasting our time.

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (Tug)

I have found IEC contactors unreliable with low quality marine grade power).
It may not be the power that is crappy.
We had a customer with an outside bridge crane with IEC contactors controlling wound rotor motors.
The power quality was excellent.
Almost every foggy morning one of the IEC contactors would flash over phase to phase and our service man would be out replacing fuses.
We replaced all of the IEC contactors with NEMA contactors and never had another problem.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

(OP)
thank you all again for participating,
As I have 10 cases, we have sent 2 motors to different workshops for rewinding and ordered another new one 220v 60hz and we will compare results.

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Well you have chosen the most expensive option.
There has been quite a bit of misinformation here from persons who may know a lot about electricity but have never done a frequency conversion.
As someone who has years of hands on experience I am appalled by some of the misinformation that has been posted here.
Your voltage is too low for 60 Hz operation.
You tell us that your motor works but is overheating.
Overheating is a symptom of low voltage.
When I was in a position to deal with burned out motors, the rule of thumb was that it was cheaper to replace motors less than 10 HP than to rewind them.
An exception was motors with special shafts or mounting arrangements.

I suggest that you try running one motor on a voltage close to 264 Volts and check both the results and the cost.
Alternately, if 460V/60Hz (or 230V/60Hz)
I have done a lot of successful frequency and voltage conversions over the years and have never even had to considere a rewind.

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

For comparison, a 3 phase 2 horsepower electric motor costs $300-800 USD. A rewind starts at $2500 USD. Maybe you have inexpensive labor available?

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

At least the OP is doing three different trials to see how best to proceed with the remaining seven; who knows, if two of the three tests don't give satisfactory results two of them might get be redone as well.

Something tells me price will be the deciding factor, with performance fighting to even get a seat at the table.

CR

"As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another." [Proverbs 27:17, NIV]

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (Tug)

For comparison, a 3 phase 2 horsepower electric motor costs $300-800 USD
I agree with you Tug, but with two comments;
1. A 2 HP positive displacement pump may have a special shaft or mounting. That will push up the cost of a replacement.
2. Don't forget the cost of the 3 phase starter.
And a rewind will change the optimum voltage to be more in line with the proper Volts-per-Hertz ratio.
It's generally easier and cheaper to change the voltage. (Done it many times)

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

nsalhieh (Industrial)(OP)22 Nov 23 07:59
"...As I have 10 cases, we have sent 2 motors to different workshops for rewinding and ordered another new one 220v 60hz and we will compare results."
I have the following opinion for your consideration.
1. One of the very important factors is the speed, a pump at 1385rpm @ 50Hz will be running 1662 rpm @ 60Hz. The power (1.85kW @ 50Hz) will be increased to (> 1.85 kW @ 60Hz), with increase in volume. Check with the pump OEM the new kW @ 1662rpm. When you rewind or order a new motor, it should be rated for the (new kW rating at 1662rpm 60Hz), as advised by the pump OEM.
2. Fine you are trying out difference solutions.
3. I strongly recommend consider try out a 3-phase new kW based on the Pump OEM advice, with the voltage and frequency based on the system on board. Note: a) A 3-phase motor eliminates the starting capacitor, centrifugal switch totally. b) with new kW (>1.85kW per pump OEM advice) and voltage rated based on the system voltage on board. NO transformer/auto-transformer is required.
Che Kuan Yau (Singapore)

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Bill

Quote (Overheating is a symptom of low voltage.)


Not necessarily. If 220 V/60 Hz got the motor up to speed, then any higher V/Hz will only increase the current with a poorer PF. (More magnetization current than real KW work current).

If 220 V/60 Hz did not get it up to speed, then a higher V/Hz would have helped reduce the current but it still could be more than the motor could handle depending on the pump demand.

If OP had a variable auto transformer, he could have tested the motor from 220 V to 264 V, 60 Hz and found the sweet spot of the lowest current and seen if the motor is still getting overheated before sending it for a rewind.

If the pump KW demand at 60 Hz is more than the motor could handle, rewinding it isn't gonna help.

Muthu
www.edison.co.in

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

I don't need a primer on motors.
Read the posts.
They applied 220V/60 Hz to a motor rated 220V/50 Hz and it is overheating.
Judging from some of the misinformation posted here, (yourself possibly excepted) I may be one of the few here who has successfully done both frequency conversions and voltage conversions.
There are two simple steps:
1. Apply the correct voltage for the new frequency.
2. Use one of several methods to reduce the load if the higher speed causes overloading.
And a special case for capacitor run motors; Adjust the run capacitor rating. (I will defer to your advice as to the proper run capacitor for 60 Hz.)
Only if this is not successful will other conversion methods be considered.
By the way, I have never had to consider other methods.
I have a serious question for you. Could too much run capacitor capacity be increasing the voltage across the winding and pushing it into saturation? (That is when the run capacitor is used in series to shift the phase angle of the start winding and not for PF correction)

--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Before redesigning the motor itself, I would test what happens if the motor is connected via an auto-transformer at 264 V.
It is possible that you may need to experiment with the values of capacitors. Also, the centrifugal switch (if it exists) could still cause problems by disconnecting the starting capacitor before the motor reaches sufficient momentum. BTW, is really starting capacitor 40µF?
If there is a possibility in site, the best option would be to redesign the motor from single-phase to three-phase.
Single-phase motors are a 'necessary evil' and should be avoided whenever possible.
ACW

RE: Want to rewind motor (single phase 220v 50 hz) into (single phase 220v 60 hz)

Quote (zlatkodo)

Before redesigning the motor itself, I would test what happens if the motor is connected via an auto-transformer at 264 V.
Thank you for the support.

Quote (OP)

actually, we run it as its and we got over heat and......
The starting switch seems to be working.
--------------------
Ohm's law
Not just a good idea;
It's the LAW!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login



News


Close Box

Join Eng-Tips® Today!

Join your peers on the Internet's largest technical engineering professional community.
It's easy to join and it's free.

Here's Why Members Love Eng-Tips Forums:

Register now while it's still free!

Already a member? Close this window and log in.

Join Us             Close