Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
(OP)
Hello All,
I have some disagreements with the A.I with Code related issues (I can give more details if needed)
The thing is, I think that something needs to be done in one way and the A.I disagree.
I gave him a lot of interpretation and quotes from the Code showing I am right.
But he keeps tell me that he will not approve.
The question is a bit general, does the A.I can tell me to do something just because "he said so"? Is there any paragraph in the Code stated that the A.I need to give background and evidence to his decisions?
I have some disagreements with the A.I with Code related issues (I can give more details if needed)
The thing is, I think that something needs to be done in one way and the A.I disagree.
I gave him a lot of interpretation and quotes from the Code showing I am right.
But he keeps tell me that he will not approve.
The question is a bit general, does the A.I can tell me to do something just because "he said so"? Is there any paragraph in the Code stated that the A.I need to give background and evidence to his decisions?
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
Also, U-2(f): "The rules of this Division shall serve as the basis for the inspector to: Perform he required Duties, authorize the application of the Certification Mark, Sign the Certificate of shop inspection."
The inspector should be able to show you in the Code where you are deficient. Call the AIA....then ASME themselves.
Curious as to the issue.
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
-Christine
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
When I was an AI, I never made a call without a reference, and always made an effort to work with the client to find a solution. Try to work with your AI and find that solution. Honestly if this is a sticking point, THEY should be contacting their supervisor well before you to make sure they are making a good call. Some AIA's will give great support, others will ignore you and let the AI handle everything. Good luck.
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
The company I work in has an "S" stamp and we manufacturing a very small size (boilers that do not exceed the limits of PMB-2.1) Electrical Boilers.
The BEP is mechanically assembled, not welded.
A.I wants that our Q.C personals, which perform NDE (mostly P.T and visual examinations) will be qualified and certified per ASME B31.1.
I don’t see any reason for that, maybe I am wrong.
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
Quality Mamual.
level 1
RE: Disagreements with the Authorized Inspector
Sometimes bringing others into a discussion especially those that are higher up can create a new dialogue that can yield an understanding.
I have done this a few times with inspectors actually and it always work.
Good luck