CGA S 1.3 Flow Primary and Secondary Requirements
CGA S 1.3 Flow Primary and Secondary Requirements
(OP)
I am new to understanding the CGA code. I see that it provides 2 flow requirements. When selecting a relief valve, which requirement needs to be met?
It was my understanding that the reclosing relief device, aka pressure relief valve, needs to only meet the system's primary flow requirement. The burst disk needs to meet the secondary flow requirement. Can someone correct my understanding here?
Also, what if my vessel does not have a burst disk, is that case, it is ok to just meet the system's primary flow requirement?
Thanks!
It was my understanding that the reclosing relief device, aka pressure relief valve, needs to only meet the system's primary flow requirement. The burst disk needs to meet the secondary flow requirement. Can someone correct my understanding here?
Also, what if my vessel does not have a burst disk, is that case, it is ok to just meet the system's primary flow requirement?
Thanks!
RE: CGA S 1.3 Flow Primary and Secondary Requirements
You may find some answers from the following link or repost your question in a more appropriate section of these forums. Good luck.
https://www.cganet.com/use-updated-cga-s-1-2-to-pr...
Per ISO-4126, only the term Safety Valve is used regardless of application or design.
RE: CGA S 1.3 Flow Primary and Secondary Requirements
Bulk LIN cryogenic tanks of substantial volume almost always have both a relief valve and rupture disk. Relief valves are typically sized for NER, PB heat load, loss of vacuum, pump filling etc. Rupture disks are typically sized for the fire case set to 110% of MAWP at 800F. I would not recommend just putting in a rupture disk. In extended periods of low usage pressure will build up enough in the tank to open a PSV or blow a rupture disk. Doesn't make sense to lose the entire tank contents just because LIN hasn't been used for X days.
----------------------------------
Not making a decision is a decision in itself
RE: CGA S 1.3 Flow Primary and Secondary Requirements
If the primary device has sufficient capacity for the emergency scenario, then is it still necessary to install a secondary relief device? You'll find that answer in the standard. If installation of a secondary device is mandatory it will say that one "shall" be installed or that one is "required". This is a prescriptive standard, so you don't have discretion to apply your own judgment to the requirements.