Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

Register Log in
  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Mentioning engineering on a web page 1

Status
Not open for further replies.
WARose

WARose

Structural
Mar 17, 2011
5,594
I noticed on a company's web site today where they mention mechanical engineering as if it is a service they offer. But these people don't have a COA for the state(s) they operate in.....and they don't have a EOR as far as I can tell (unless he/she is outside the company).

Is that ethical? Or could that fall under the industrial exemption?
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Sort by date Sort by votes
Depends on whether the mention can be construed as an offer to practice engineering for the public. Something like, "Our rigorous mechanical engineering provide the user with a robust and reliable product" would be protected by the industrial exemption in a state like California.

TTFN (ta ta for now)
I can do absolutely anything. I'm an expert! faq731-376 forum1529 Entire Forum list
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
It certainly appears to me as though they are offering Mechanical Engineering services to the general public. To do so the company would need to be registered with the states in which they do business and may also need a PE on staff. I'm not sure if contracting with an independent engineer would qualify.

As far as the ethics are concerned, it could be that this company is unaware of the legal requirements for offering engineering services. If they are aware and choose to offer engineering services anyway then that is a different matter.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Looks like their mechanical design would be for machine parts. I tactually says engineering, not design. This may be on purpose.
It is between them and the client to determine if the exemption applies.

They likely would design a part of equipment and their client designs the whole machine (or whatever)
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
The company is located in the state of Georgia. Georgia has a very limited exemption for industry and this company does not appear to fit that exemption. It is primarily for defense and aerospace companies. Further Section 43-15-30 of the Georgia Engineering Law, "Unlawful acts" indicates that this company is in violation, which is a misdemeanor. The terms "Engineer" and "Engineering" are protected terms under this section of the statute, thus they are violating this.

 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I was on their side until I got to this page: [URL unfurl="true"]https://www.davisvibration.com/mechanical_engineering.htm[/url]

I was hoping it was just a "we can handle the engineering (through our outside consultants)" but failed to add the last part. But this jumps over the line I think.

I'm guessing you verified the lack of CoA/License through an online portal?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I don't see how this wouldn't be covered by the industrial exemption. It applies to a lot more than some people think. For example, I have designed medical devices, including medical implants, lab equipment, telecom equipment, consumer devices, industrial equipment, aerospace/defense, etc, all without needing a PE or even employing any PEs in the company. This was all perfectly legal.

It looks like they are not suggesting they will design your power plant that uses large rotating equipment, just that they have an engineer that can help with your vibration issues by maybe designing a custom coupling or monitoring system.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
hendersdc - keep in mind that state laws vary. You may be spot on in Colorado. Ron practices mostly in Florida, and I'd be surprised if he's not registered in and quite knowledgeable about Georgia's professional practice laws as well. His presentation is certainly convincing.

The problem comes from the fact that they have a section of their website titled "Mechanical Engineering" and say "Contact us to discuss your requirements for our mechanical engineering services." If they said "Contact us to discuss the requirements for your custom equipment" they'd probably be fine. But the way its worded implies that they will provide mechanical engineering services to the public.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
phamENG,

I see what you are saying now, I guess I am just assuming that when they are contacted the scope of their offerings would end up being limited only to what is exempt.

For example, here is the website of the company I work for (I hope this doesn't count as advertising, if it does please remove the link) [URL unfurl="true"]https://www.creationtech.com/solutions/product-development-and-engineering/[/url]. It also says engineering, I consider myself a mechanical engineer, and offer mechanical engineering services to our clients. All of this takes place in exclusively exempt industries.

Is the consensus that we need to have an asterisk and a footnote somewhere that says "Engineering services only offered in exempt industries"?
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
I'm guessing you verified the lack of CoA/License through an online portal?
Click to expand...

Yep. And they don't.

(And actually I am wondering (since I am licensed in Ga) do I have a obligation to turn them in?)

But I was kind of intrigued with this site in terms of interpreting if they are really saying they offer engineering services.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
hendersdc - like I said, you may be fine. CO may have more relaxed laws than GA. Some states require an engineering license if you mention the word engineering - there's a thread floating around here somewhere about a guy who prepared and delivered a presentation to his city council about some traffic development, and somebody on the other side convinced the board they were "practicing engineering" and they issued a fine.

So you can offer your product to the public and that may will involve engineering it, but you can't offer engineering in an open ended sense.

WARose - I'd send something to the company. Say hey, I saw you have this on your website, and I think you're violating XYZ. Maybe you should revise it to such-and-such. Thanks and have a great day. If they ignore you or don't change it, then send it the board.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
somebody on the other side convinced the board they were "practicing engineering" and they issued a fine.
Click to expand...

In Oregon, and the board eventually lost and had to eat crow

if they are really saying they offer engineering services.
Click to expand...

They are, and would be fine in California, but's Georgia's law looks way more restrictive

TTFN (ta ta for now)
I can do absolutely anything. I'm an expert! faq731-376 forum1529 Entire Forum list
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
This isn't just in CO, our company headquarters are in Boston and we do work for customers in many states and countries. In our industry (EMS) and the industries of our customers a PE just isn't needed. Though I can't specifically remember doing work for a customer in Georgia we wouldn't turn down someone just because they were based there.

As further examples, all the major competitors in our industry all mention "engineering" services on their websites. These aren't small companies either, combined revenue is in the 10's of billions:

[URL unfurl="true"]https://plexus.com/en-us/solutions[/url]
[URL unfurl="true"]https://flex.com/product-lifecycle/design-and-develop/advanced-engineering[/url]
[URL unfurl="true"]https://www.bench.com/engineering-capabilities[/url]

I did see the thread/article about the traffic analysis as well, he actually had the board's decision overturned by a federal court, partially due to the boards "history of overzealous enforcement": [URL unfurl="true"]https://ij.org/press-release/oregon-engineer-wins-traffic-light-timing-lawsuit/[/url]
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Not sure how to take it. Although, I've never 100% gotten the industrial exemption anyway (i.e. where it is applicable).
Click to expand...

The industrial exemption is simple - you need a license to work for the public; you dont need a license to work for a business. In this case GA 43-15-29 governs. The main page of the website clearly states that their customers are industrial plants. Moreover, common sense says that the general public isnt going to hire an industrial balancing outfit. Therefore, this clearly falls under the industrial exemption as they are NOT advertising to the general public, they are advertising toward businesses.

Given the number of times the exemption has been explained on this board, the fact that it is a tested item on licensing exams and discussed in required ethics courses, I cant help but wonder if these posts are often a clumsy political lobbying attempt.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Given the number of times the exemption has been explained on this board, the fact that it is a tested item on licensing exams and discussed in required ethics courses, I cant help but wonder if these posts are often a clumsy political lobbying attempt.
Click to expand...

Woah.....somebody had a little too much caffeine this morning. As Steve Martin use to say "well excuuuuuse meee" for not knowing (or being 100% sure) how the industrial exemption applies in the state of Georgia.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
CWB1 said:
they are NOT advertising to the general public, they are advertising toward businesses.
Click to expand...

Architectural firms are businesses. So you're saying that if I ONLY advertise to architectural firms, I don't need a license to practice structural engineering?

CWB1 said:
you dont need a license to work for a business.
Click to expand...

I agree, but would phrase it differently. You don't need a license to be an employee of a business. Offering a service to a private company IS offering it to the public.

For what it's worth, I'm giving these guys the benefit of the doubt. What they are doing is probably within the bounds of the industrial exemption. BUT, the way they present it on their website appears to go beyond what's allowed.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
For what it's worth, I'm giving these guys the benefit of the doubt. What they are doing is probably within the bounds of the industrial exemption.
Click to expand...

To me the gray area of the exemption is stuff like this: (from GA 43-15-29)

(c) This chapter shall not be construed as requiring registration for the purpose of practicing professional engineering or land surveying by an individual, firm, or corporation on property owned or leased by such individual, firm, or corporation unless the same involves the public safety or public health or for the performance of engineering which relates solely to the design or fabrication of manufactured products.

Ok how is public safety not involved if (for example) a guy working on/engineering a piece of equipment causes it to blow out and start a fire and a toxic chemical is released in the air? To me, it's fairly nebulous as to where the public safety ends and this applies.
 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Georgia's law is pretty strict on the IE. I fell under one while I was working in North Carolina (though I was licensed as a condition of my employment anyway). It's a little more broad:

North Carolina S89C-25 said:
This Chapter shall not prevent the following activities:
8. (ii) the performance of internal engineering or survey work by amanufacturingor communications common carrier company, or by a research and development company, or by employees of those corporations provided that the work is in connection with, or incidental to products of, or nonengineering services rendered by those corporationsor their affiliates.9. The routine maintenance or servicing of machinery, equipment, facilities or structures, the work of mechanics in the performance of their established functions, or the inspection or supervision of construction by a foreman, superintendent, or agent of the architect or professional engineer, or servicesof an operational nature performed by an employee of a laboratory, a manufacturing plant, a public service corporation, or governmental operation.
Click to expand...

I think of it this way:

If I want to create a widget, I can design it and have somebody make it, and then sell it, all without being an engineer. If it breaks and falls apart, then I'll lose my shirt in the marketplace and nobody cares. If it breaks and falls apart and somebody gets hurt, then more than likely there's some other regulation that's going to require rigorous testing to prove it's safe.

Now if I design a widget but want to make sure it won't fall apart, I can send it to somebody to go over the design and improve/optimize it (or maybe do the whole design based on a conceptual idea I had) - somebody to engineer it. THAT PERSON has to be licensed, because they are offering engineering as a service. Then, once I have the design from them, I send it to the factory to have it made.

 
Upvote 0 Downvote
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

RacknRoll
  • Question
Engineering 1
Replies
10
Views
5K
IRstuff
IRstuff
strguy11
  • Question
QA/QC Process Structural Engineering Firm
Replies
3
Views
421
CWB1
CWB1
RVAmeche
  • Locked
  • Question
3rd Party Engineering Services without a PE Stamp? 5
Replies
18
Views
2K
dauwerda
dauwerda
mfstructural
  • Locked
  • Question
Structural Engineering New Building Design Fees
Replies
3
Views
5K
W460x68
W460x68
cray54
  • Locked
  • Question
Seeking Advice Re: Business Entity Type - Engineering Exemption in MA
Replies
8
Views
1K
jhnblgr
jhnblgr

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top Bottom