×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Contact US

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

(OP)
Good Morning,

Can anyone explain how I use the AISC Design Guide-9 diagrams in Appendix-C to determine the rotation and derivative functions for concentrated torsions applied at locations other than 0.1, 0.3 and 0.5 from the member end? The Design Guide doesn't appear to explain this anywhere and I have moments at 0.38 and 0.05 from my member end for instance.

I'd appreciate any help with this!

Best regards,

jochav52802

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

Are you looking at Case 3 or Case 6, the general form rotation equations are at appendix section C.4 you need to differentiate them with respect to z, d/dz, 3 times to get the other needed equations.

units for my equations below:
T - Kip*in
G - Kip/in^2
J - in^4
l - in

Here are the equations I have for Case 3:

CODE --> python

Theta:
        if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
            theta = ((T*l) / (G*J))*(((1.0-alpha)*(z/l))+(((a/l)*((sinh((alpha*l)/a)/tanh(l/a)) - cosh((alpha*l)/a)))*sinh(z/a)))
        else:
            theta = ((T*l) / (G*J))*(((l-z)*(alpha/l))+((a/l)*(((sinh((alpha*l)/a) / tanh(l/a))*sinh(z/a)) -(sinh((alpha*l)/a)*m.cosh(z/a)))))
            
        Theta':
        if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
            theta_prime = ((-1.0*T)/(G*J))*(alpha - 1.0 + (cosh(z/a)*((cosh((l*alpha)/a) - (sinh((l*alpha)/a)/tanh(l/a))))))
        else:
            theta_prime = -1.0*((T*(alpha - m.cosh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a)/tanh(l/a) + sinh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/(G*J)))
       
        Theta'':
        if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
            theta_doubleprime = -((T*sinh(z/a)*(cosh((l*alpha)/a) - sinh((l*alpha)/a)/tanh(l/a)))/(a*G*J))
        else:
            theta_doubleprime = (T*(-1.0*m.cosh(z/a) + sinh(z/a)/tanh(l/a))*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/(a*G*J)
       
        Theta''':
        if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
            theta_tripleprime = -((T*m.cosh(z/a)*(m.cosh((l*alpha)/a) - sinh((l*alpha)/a)/tanh(l/a)))/(G*J*a**2))
        else:
            theta_tripleprime = (T*(m.cosh(z/a)/tanh(l/a) - sinh(z/a))*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/(G*J*a**2) 

Case 6: (double check this one my memory is failing me if I fully tested this one)

CODE --> python

H = (((1.0-cosh((alpha*l)/a)) / tanh(l/a)) + ((cosh((alpha*l)/a)-1.0) / sinh(l/a)) + sinh((alpha*l)/a) - ((alpha*l)/a)) / (((cosh(l/a)+(cosh((alpha*l)/a)*cosh(l/a))-cosh((alpha*l)/a)-1.0)/sinh(l/a))+((l/a)*(alpha-1.0))-sinh((alpha*l)/a))
	
theta:
if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
	thet = ((T*a) / ((H+1.0)*G*J))*((((H*((1.0/sinh(l/a))+sinh((alpha*l)/a)-(cosh((alpha*l)/a)/tanh(l/a))))+(sinh((alpha*l)/a) - (cosh((alpha*l)/a)/tanh(l/a)) + (1.0/tanh(l/a))))* (cosh(z/a)-1.0)) - sinh(z/a) + (z/a))
else:
	thet = (T*a / ((1+(1/H))*G*J))*((cosh((alpha*l)/a) - 1.0/(H*sinh(l/a)) +(cosh((alpha*l)/a)-cosh(l/a)+((l/a)*sinh(l/a))) / sinh(l/a)) +cosh(z/a)*((1.0-cosh((alpha*l)/a))/(H*tanh(l/a)) +(1.0-(cosh((alpha*l)/a)*cosh(l/a)))/sinh(l/a)) +sinh(z/a)*(((cosh((alpha*l)/a)-1.0)/H) + cosh((alpha*l)/a)) -(z/a))

theta':
if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
	theta_prime = (-1.0*T*(-1.0 + cosh(z/a) + (-1.0 + (1.0 + H)*cosh((l*alpha)/a))*(sinh(z/a)/tanh(l/a)) - 1.0*H*(sinh(z/a)/sinh(l/a)) - 1.0*sinh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a) - 1.0*H*sinh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a)))/(G*(1.0 + H)*J)
else:
	theta_prime = 0

theta'':
if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
	theta_doubleprime = -((T*((cosh(z/a)*(-1.0 + (1.0 + H)*(cosh((l*alpha)/a))/tanh(l/a)))/a - (H*(cosh(z/a)/sinh(l/a)))/a + sinh(z/a)/a - (cosh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/a - (H*cosh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/a))/(G*(1.0 + H)*J))
else:
	theta_doubleprime = 0
   
theta''':
if 0 <= z_in <= (alpha*l):
	theta_tripleprime = -((T*(cosh(z/a)/a**2 + ((-1.0 + (1.0 + H)*(cosh((l*alpha)/a))/tanh(l/a))*sinh(z/a))/a**2 - (H*(sinh(z/a)/sinh(l/a)))/a**2 - (sinh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/a**2 - (H*sinh(z/a)*sinh((l*alpha)/a))/a**2))/(G*(1.0 + H)*J))
else:
	theta_tripleprime = 0 

Open Source Structural Applications: https://github.com/buddyd16/Structural-Engineering

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

(OP)
Much appreciated Celt83!

Best regards,

jochav52802

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

just to be extra clear scrutinize my equations I've only done some minimal validation comparing a few values for z and alpha*L with the charts provided in design guide 9.

Open Source Structural Applications: https://github.com/buddyd16/Structural-Engineering

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

oh man structSU10 I can't star/thank you enough for that doing these derivations by hand has been brutal.

Open Source Structural Applications: https://github.com/buddyd16/Structural-Engineering

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

Jochav52802:
Years ago, Bethlehem Steel had a great publication, “Torsion Analysis of Rolled Steel Sections,” on the subject of Torsional Analysis, it was the bible at the time. Although I don’t have the later editions of this material or the AISC Design Guides, I believe that AISC basically took this publication over at some point in time, and I suspect it is part of their current Design Guide on the subject (Design Guide 9?). The format and equations that StructSU10 attached are essentially the same as those in my 1963 ed. It also had a good bibliography, for that time, for some deeper reading on the original thinking and development of this material; all the great old names and titles which no one, today, even seems to know ever existed. I can remember doing some of this same development years ago, and as for a better understanding of the basic subject, I don’t think Google will never replace touching and reading some of these authors and pages.

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

(OP)
Thanks a lot everyone,

I have to brush up on my differentiation skills to verify Celt83's equations. To make things simpler, I just clustered portions of a the equations that were composed of multiple constants as a single constant, which made differentiation much easier to see. All I needed to know was the derivative of a constant in front of z and the derivative of the hyperbolic trig functions as a function of z.

Man, now I know why we should just avoid torsion from the outset; what a pain this is!

Best regards,

jochav52802

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

(OP)
Hello All,

One more question, the Case-3 chart with Alpha set to 0.5 indicates that at midspan, theta' should be zero. When I take the first derivative of theta and plug in the z-value corresponding to the midspan of the beam, I don't get a theta' value equal to zero. This would seem to suggest that my theta' equation is wrong, but my theta'' and theta''' equations are correct as they match the stresses from example 5.1 of Design Guide-9.

I'd appreciate any advice here.

Thank you,

jochav52802

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

(OP)
Hello Celt83,

Would you mind clarifying what the "m" represents in your theta''' equation for case-3?

Additionally, would you explain why you multiplied your derivative formulas by -1? I'd imagine that it was for some sort of convenience, but am not seeing it.

Thank you,

jochav52802

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

Take a look at the resource StructSU10 posted it has the derivatives in reduced form.

That m. Your are seeing was left over from my python code you can ignore it. Been awhile since I did those derivatives but I think one of the hyperbolics results in sign inverse when you do the derivative.

Open Source Structural Applications: https://github.com/buddyd16/Structural-Engineering

RE: AISC Design Guide-9: How to interpolate rotation functions for other concent. mom. positons

(OP)
Thank you Celt83,

I found an error in my excel formula for the Theta', so now everything's working. Thanks for the clarification on the "m" and just for you information, the derivative for cosh or sinh don't produce a negative sign, so I think you must have used the negative for convenience.


Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login


Resources

Low-Volume Rapid Injection Molding With 3D Printed Molds
Learn methods and guidelines for using stereolithography (SLA) 3D printed molds in the injection molding process to lower costs and lead time. Discover how this hybrid manufacturing process enables on-demand mold fabrication to quickly produce small batches of thermoplastic parts. Download Now
Design for Additive Manufacturing (DfAM)
Examine how the principles of DfAM upend many of the long-standing rules around manufacturability - allowing engineers and designers to place a part’s function at the center of their design considerations. Download Now
Taking Control of Engineering Documents
This ebook covers tips for creating and managing workflows, security best practices and protection of intellectual property, Cloud vs. on-premise software solutions, CAD file management, compliance, and more. Download Now

Close Box

Join Eng-Tips® Today!

Join your peers on the Internet's largest technical engineering professional community.
It's easy to join and it's free.

Here's Why Members Love Eng-Tips Forums:

Register now while it's still free!

Already a member? Close this window and log in.

Join Us             Close