In the modern world people are far more adept at job hopping.
To expect people to remain in one place for long is unrealistic.
However, if you don't offer incentives to stay for longer you lose useful people quicker than you can train them and get left with the no-hopers.
Training adds value.
It does make people more employable by others.
But it also acts as an incentive to encourage people to stay longer where they can add value to themselves quicker.
The issue then is for the employer to try and come out ahead on the cost benefit side of the game.
Employees with ambitions are often better employees. Not always, but often.
Good employers will recognise that they can attract the best employees if they help those employees meet their own goals which may well be to move on to better jobs.
HR's function is succession planning.
People can do funny things like leave to work for some one else or get run over by buses.
Funnily enough the one area that seems to defeat HR succession planning is retirement. They know that if so and so doesn't get the sack or hand in his notice or get hit by a bus, come his 65th birthday he is out of the door.
Usually HR catch on to this about one or two days before he actually retires.
Plus it seems that the more valuable the employee the closer to retirement before they realise the problem.
Go figure.
It makes you wonder bout working your notice period too.
I can't say I have ever had a constructive well thought out plan put to me for my notice period.
In some companies, if they think you are going to a competitor, they will let you go immediately. I have never understood why because if your leaving is a surprise to them, it isn't to you and if you were going to do anything tricky, you'd have done it already.
The first job I left they decided to keep me as long as possible to spite the competitor I was going to but took me off normal duties and gave me a special project which I did to the best of my ability, even though I was the last one to arrive at the pub for my own leaving party.
I have never been asked to help transfer anything to a successor.
The most I have been asked to do is make sure everything on my laptop was organised onto the company mainframe for future reference but I have never seen any sign that anyone ever used it.
But who ever said management or HR were smart?
JMW