JLSeagull,
Conventional butterfly (centered) are normally rubber or Teflon seated, and although limited in applications (heat, medium & pressure), normally give THE best sealing performances (for their intended service).
I would disagree with "the shutoff performance is poor", I may have less to say about throttling (as this is not the intended service), I may even agree with torque curve requirements (vortex, that changes with shape of disc); But generally they are good for what they have been intentionally designed to do.
Ciao