So you're saying that abbreviations used in spec A must stand for the same thing in spec B? W means in CAN be welded? and the P means. . . it can be welded to pipe? or it is a piping product? Or it is just a product?
Yes, I know what weldable means, but I appreciate your condescension. If W means weldable, then why doesn't every single piece of weldable material carry WP, or at least W, in the designation? Regardless of whether it is of welded or seamless construction, if it CAN be welded to something else, it should have a W in the designation, right? Following your assertion:
SA-312 TP304L should be changed to SA-312 WP304L. After all, it can be welded, and it is certainly a pipe product form. SA-105 fittings should be SA-105 WP. After all, they can be welded, and they can be welded to pipe. SA-516 Gr.70 should be changed to SA-516 WPGr.70. After all, it can be welded, and it can be welded to pipe. SA-240 317 should be SA-240 WP317. SB-111 C70600 should be changed to SB-111 WPC70600. After all, it can be welded, and it can be welded to pipe, should a person desire. I could go on forever.
I'm not going to badger back and forth. WP means wrought product. TP means tubular product (not tube or pipe). I think discerning minds can tell when someone is either grasping at straws or refuses to acknowledge an inaccurate interpretation.
-TJ Orlowski