Your intended preheat is pretty good, but I'd go even higher. What you want to do is avoid cooling thru the range of ~1,300 to 1,000 deg F too fast. This will allow time for the austenite in the HAZ to transform to pearlite.
I did a little study with a low alloy steel (P3) welded with the worst case-a single pass. Preheating to 400 deg. F. wasn't high enough, but we never did go back and try higher temps.