Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations The Obturator on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

stress in two planks

Status
Not open for further replies.

technicalgirlca

Mechanical
Apr 12, 2009
2
if i have two 8x10 can i combine them and calculate the stress over the combined thickensss
thanks
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

combine them how ... to get ...
16*10, 8*20, 10*16.

and then how are the loads oriented to the joint ?

and what is the primary load ... bending or compression ?

 
Good questions, rb1957. My question is "since when is an 8x10 a plank?"
 
it'd be a very thick one, or a very narrow one ;)
 
Generally not. If they're the same thickness and size, you could figure each carried half the load. But that's not the same as figuring one plank twice as thick.

Consider why a cable if flexible, but a bar of the same size is not.
 
Bond, or fasten, the 2 8x10, then calculate as composite.
Otherwise, the above is accurate enough for practical purpose.
 
For two beams combined, the bending stiffness will be determined by the addition of the 2nd Moment of Inertias, ie. bd^3/6. This assumes the worst case that there is no friction between them and they slide. If you bolt the two together, however, then the MOI will be based upon the combined thickness, ie. (2/3)bd^3

corus
 
I ususally assume each one carries half the load - assuming that the load rests rather evenly on each one. Fasten together to act as one beam.
 
we're assuming this is a beam ... what if this is a column ?

if it is a beam, and they're just stacked on top of each other, and there's a point load on the upper one, then doesn't the lower beam provide a distributed reaction to the upper ? ... IMHO not the same as saying each reacts 1/2
 
Looks like technicalgirlca needs to provide a bit more information.

BA
 

It seems that technicalgirlca is not actively following this thread. A clarification of the specific application is in order - beam or column? orientation of the (2) 8x10s as rb1957 stated?

Ralph
 
Column will be lousier to address - side aways + compression. Difficult to justfied the 50/50 approach.
 
You can make them a composite wood beam using the shear flow equation VQ/Ib to determine the ingerstitial shear generated at the intersection from your particular loads. Based on this shear value, you can determine the size and spacing of the thru-bolts to accomplish the composite action. This is assuming that the members are placed one on top of the other.

However, if they are placed side by side, they are just the two original beams. They should still be stitch bolted together, but this is mainly to get them to deflect uniformly, sharing the same load.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
 
if they're on top of each other, no. unless you connect them and check horizontal shear.

if they're side by side, technically no.....but you'd be splitting the load in half anyway between the two members, so numerically, it'll come out that way.

whoops, msquared already said it.

LOL.
 
we've all said lot's of things ... but we need to OP to chime in ... beam or column ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor