Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Solid parts are shown as hollow in drafting while taking section 3

Status
Not open for further replies.

venomex

Automotive
Jan 12, 2015
92
I have an assembly where I have a part from Catia(rest are NX parts), though it is a solid while taking a sectional view of assembly only the outermost and innermost faces/lines are shown. The same problem appears in 3d part modelling environment.

I have loaded the exact parts and same problem persists.
Is there a way to solve this?

Pratham Shetty,
Daimler Buses.
Using NX 9.0.3.4
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

I just had a similar case.
Please have a closer look at the part that has the problem;
Make it displayed part.
In my case I had intersecting bodies in one part. The part had an intersecting wave-link body.

Now go to Assemblies / Reference Sets and pick "Model"
2015-05-20_04_dtvfkz.gif

You will probably see more than one body selected.
In that case de-select the wave linked body(ies). Make sure you now have only one body selected in the "Model" Reference Set.
Now return to the top assembly and hopefully no more "hollow" parts are visible.

In the View Section Dialog you can Check [V] "Show Interference" under the "Cap Settings" tab. If an interference is still present, the cut face will be highlighted in red instead of green (or hollow).
2015-05-20_03_omt1fs.gif


I hope this helps you.
It helped me. GTAC Benelux was very helpful. :)

Greetings,
Frank

2x NX9.0.3.4 and NX10.0.24 Mach Design
on win7 64bit
NX Beta Tester
1x Solid Edge ST2
 
What Version of JT file are you viewing from Catia in your assembly? I assume it is a JT file from Catia? If it is an older JT file generated from Catia you will see this happen. I can not remember the JT version I think it was 9 (Very unsure on this) that works well with NX. We had this same issues with our Older I-Deas JT data when we tried to view it in NX. To check you JT version you will have to export the JT file out as a named reference and open the JT file with Notepad. The version of JT file will be a the top.
 
Thanks Frank, SDETERS, Jerry.

It seems that there were multiple bodies within Catia part in the reference set as you said. I usually keep the interfrence option on by default, but I missed it this time.My mistake.

And my JT file version was 9.5. I learned something new. So I suppose version 9+ catia JTs work well as SDETERS said.

Thanks a ton people...

Pratham Shetty,
Daimler Buses.
Using NX 9.0.3.4
 
I am getting the same error again now. After the short moment of success, I entered drating where it showed same hollow like surface, so I switched back to the part model, and sectioned the view after checking overlapping of other parts, it showed hollow parts...


Pratham Shetty,
Daimler Buses.
Using NX 9.0.3.4
 
I reloaded the assembly without saving and the sections were back to normal ie clean solid body sections. Could the file be corrupted or glitch in NX?

Pratham Shetty,
Daimler Buses.
Using NX 9.0.3.4
 
Pratham,

Does the JT file have a body where the body is not a single color (one or more faces have a different color assigned than the body color)?

If so, please try using File-> Properties - JT file -> Extract exact data" and edit the face colors to all use one color. Then File -> Export JT using the uniform color body to a new JT file and then test the sectioning on that JT file.

Hope This Helps,

Joe
 
@jpetach
The extract exact data is not highlighted, maybe it is already exactly extracted data file.

Pratham Shetty,
Daimler Buses.
Using NX 9.0.3.4
 
Pratham,

Sorry, the "Extract Exact" step is "only if needed". If the Extract button is not active just continue the process of exporting the unified color test JT file.

Does the fact that you were at the Extract Exact step mean that the JT file does contain differing colors for faces/regions?

Joe



 
@jpetach
No, the faces have same colour but since I had no other option I was giving it a try....

Pratham Shetty,
Daimler Buses.
Using NX 9.0.3.4
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor