alansimpson
Mechanical
Can anyone recommend magnetic modelling packages both free and commersial. I would like to work out fields and forces in various permanent magnetic configurations.
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Modelling packages 3
- Thread starter alansimpson
- Start date
- Status
I use & like MagNet from Infolytica, both 2D & 3D solvers are available. Maxwell used to ignore eddy currents but I think they now have a transient solver that takes them into account. May not be important to you if you are only looking at low frequency.
- Thread starter
- #3
alansimpson
Mechanical
These packages are for electromagnetism. Would permanant magnets be the same?
Yes they certainly will cope with permanent magnets. You can enter the magnet characteristic with all the electromagnetic finite element packages, and in your model you define the direction of magnetization, it's pretty simple.
I have used the free download version of Maxwell (Ansoft), it does the basic 2-D business and it is easy to use (field patterns etc) but I did find it lacking when it came to force calculation i.e very sensitive to the mesh and generally not reliable. The full FE packages usually offer different force calculation methods (Maxwell's stress and the virtual work methods to name two) and generally are a lot better equipped. Calculation of force by two different methods also gives reassurance, it is a calculation prone to error.
The commercial packages I have used are Ansys, Algor and MagNet (the latter several years ago) - Ansys is a bit of a sledgehammer to crack a nut, Algor is quite laborious to model and mesh I thought. MagNet may be the one to go for, I have a feeling it is cheaper, and also has adaptive meshing and a macro function - both very desirable in my opinion.
You may want to ask for a free-trial, I know this is done quite often, but bear in mind there is usually a big learning curve particularly when adaptive meshing isn't available.
I have used the free download version of Maxwell (Ansoft), it does the basic 2-D business and it is easy to use (field patterns etc) but I did find it lacking when it came to force calculation i.e very sensitive to the mesh and generally not reliable. The full FE packages usually offer different force calculation methods (Maxwell's stress and the virtual work methods to name two) and generally are a lot better equipped. Calculation of force by two different methods also gives reassurance, it is a calculation prone to error.
The commercial packages I have used are Ansys, Algor and MagNet (the latter several years ago) - Ansys is a bit of a sledgehammer to crack a nut, Algor is quite laborious to model and mesh I thought. MagNet may be the one to go for, I have a feeling it is cheaper, and also has adaptive meshing and a macro function - both very desirable in my opinion.
You may want to ask for a free-trial, I know this is done quite often, but bear in mind there is usually a big learning curve particularly when adaptive meshing isn't available.
For a BEA solution, look at Lorentz [3D] and Magneto [2D] from IES. No time-consuming meshing - very quick results generation.
Gareth P. Hatch, Ph.D.
Director of Technology
Dexter Magnetic Technologies
Gareth P. Hatch, Ph.D.
Director of Technology
Dexter Magnetic Technologies
-
2
- #6
-
1
- #8
I know I'm a little late in responding (I don't wander in here much) but Arnold Magnetics has a good summary of products available that I used to help me determine which package to buy.
-Mike
-Mike
- Status