Is there a chemical kit available that can be used for verifying types of steel. In particular Cold Rolled Steel, 409 Aluminized, & 29-4C Stainless. On the occasion, the CRS can be brushed to look similar to 29-4C. The 409 Aluminized and CRS Aluminized have the same appearance.
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Metal Testing
- Thread starter Ta2
- Start date
Eh, Ta2, wouldn't you be more surprised if the two different steels, both coated with the same stuff (aluminized), DIDN'T look the same?
There are chemical spot test kits available that can distinguish between cold rolled and 409 stainless and 29-4C. Koslow, SSL, and others make them here in the States, and I'm certain other vendors exist elsewhere. Yet you'll have to remove the aluminized layer from where you are going to test, of course- and the small mark that is left may make some folks feel it is not quite non-destructive. These chemical test kits probably run in the hundreds of $, rather than tens or thousands, to give you an order of magnitude feel for the price. All depends on what you want, as always.
You can also go to electrospark spectrographs, or x-ray fluorescence analyzers. These cost thousands to tens of thousands of $. Different beasts altogether.
There are chemical spot test kits available that can distinguish between cold rolled and 409 stainless and 29-4C. Koslow, SSL, and others make them here in the States, and I'm certain other vendors exist elsewhere. Yet you'll have to remove the aluminized layer from where you are going to test, of course- and the small mark that is left may make some folks feel it is not quite non-destructive. These chemical test kits probably run in the hundreds of $, rather than tens or thousands, to give you an order of magnitude feel for the price. All depends on what you want, as always.
You can also go to electrospark spectrographs, or x-ray fluorescence analyzers. These cost thousands to tens of thousands of $. Different beasts altogether.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question