So you thought your backyard weeds were a pain. Well maybe not.
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Making rubber from dandelions 1
- Thread starter cranky108
- Start date
- Status
So you thought your backyard weeds were a pain. Well maybe not.
ornerynorsk
Industrial
Many plants have latex, I would think it would work equally well. Milkweed, Jackfruit, Burdock, nettles, thistle, just to name the ones I can immediately recall. The articles' figures for yield seem a bit optimistic.
It is better to have enough ideas for some of them to be wrong, than to be always right by having no ideas at all.
It is better to have enough ideas for some of them to be wrong, than to be always right by having no ideas at all.
msquared48
Structural
Is this a leftover from Woodstock?
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
Mike McCann, PE, SE (WA)
- Thread starter
- #4
More interesting is that the plants can also be eaten if one were hungry enough.
So natural rubber can be grown in more places, and possibly replace synthetic rubber (probally not). But it reduces the dependice on tropical land for supporting the modern world.
So natural rubber can be grown in more places, and possibly replace synthetic rubber (probally not). But it reduces the dependice on tropical land for supporting the modern world.
btrueblood
Mechanical
I like arugula better.
- Thread starter
- #8
The world of modern medicine is full of discoveries that at one time were folk medicine.
The only questions left here is if it is cheeper to produce rubber from dandelions? How do you harvest them and how fast can you make a crop out of them?
The existing process involves growing a tree, then harvesting it.
I would assume with dandelions the plant to harvest time would be much less, and the crops can be rotated from year to year. So it appears to be a process that has a quicker expantion capability to better deal with changes in demand.
The only questions left here is if it is cheeper to produce rubber from dandelions? How do you harvest them and how fast can you make a crop out of them?
The existing process involves growing a tree, then harvesting it.
I would assume with dandelions the plant to harvest time would be much less, and the crops can be rotated from year to year. So it appears to be a process that has a quicker expantion capability to better deal with changes in demand.
While time-to-first-harvest for dandelions is undoubtedly faster, my understanding is that the trees can be tapped for rubber many, many times. Productive life is ~25 years after maturity, and each tree is tapped every few days. Something like 3,000 harvests per tree.
cranky108 said:
Do they harvest rubber trees these days Cranky?
I thought they tapped them repeatedly.
Posting guidelines faq731-376 (probably not aimed specifically at you)
What is Engineering anyway: faq1088-1484
What is Engineering anyway: faq1088-1484
moltenmetal
Chemical
There are also biological routes to making cis-isoprene which involve microorganisms instead of plants or trees. None of them are commercial yet as far as I know.
They "harvest" the rubber trees at the end of their service life and make cheap furniture from them, but as noted the rubber is produced by tapping live trees and collecting the latex.
I was surprised to read on Wikipedia that natural rubber production is still about 40% of total rubber production, so I did some digging and the numbers are more or less accurate. I would have thought that SBR would have dwarfed it completely, but there you go- it's still cheap enough and the properties are great for some applications.
Where we need a bit of help is with the disposal of the used tires. They burn cleanly when burned in a properly designed combustor and have an incredibly high energy content, and are far cleaner as a fuel source than most coals. But because everybody has seen at least TV images of smoky, sooty burning tires (which is more pyrolysis than combustion), people think they are a dirty fuel and won't permit them to be burned in many jurisdictions. So instead, they sit in piles and burn by accident, creating major environmental impact even after the firefighters manage to put them out which is not easy by any stretch of the imagination. There are some re-use options (such as the use of recycled rubber crumb in asphalt etc.), and some people have tried to pyrolyze them to make liquid fuels, but there are still mountains of used tires to be found.
They "harvest" the rubber trees at the end of their service life and make cheap furniture from them, but as noted the rubber is produced by tapping live trees and collecting the latex.
I was surprised to read on Wikipedia that natural rubber production is still about 40% of total rubber production, so I did some digging and the numbers are more or less accurate. I would have thought that SBR would have dwarfed it completely, but there you go- it's still cheap enough and the properties are great for some applications.
Where we need a bit of help is with the disposal of the used tires. They burn cleanly when burned in a properly designed combustor and have an incredibly high energy content, and are far cleaner as a fuel source than most coals. But because everybody has seen at least TV images of smoky, sooty burning tires (which is more pyrolysis than combustion), people think they are a dirty fuel and won't permit them to be burned in many jurisdictions. So instead, they sit in piles and burn by accident, creating major environmental impact even after the firefighters manage to put them out which is not easy by any stretch of the imagination. There are some re-use options (such as the use of recycled rubber crumb in asphalt etc.), and some people have tried to pyrolyze them to make liquid fuels, but there are still mountains of used tires to be found.
moltenmetal
Chemical
Great to hear that TomDOT- that's exactly where they should be going in my opinion. That's where most of the chlorinated waste should be going too.
moltenmetal
Chemical
...but they do that here in northern climes already to improve the freeze tolerance. Guess there's plenty of Cl- to worry about already from road salt so what's a little more?
Yeah, the concrete guys here had a presentation on chlorides for freeze resistance - they don't think the corrosion tradeoff is generally worthwhile in our environment. Entrained air microbubbles was the preferred solution. But it's certainly not a settled subject, and we have less freeze/thaw and less road salt than most.
- Thread starter
- #18
I have heard where used tires were ground up and mixed with coal for power production (and given renewable tax credits, which I question).
Old tires aren't just used for door mats any more.
Taping a tree is not harvesting the latex? Since when is cutting down a plant the only way to harvest a crop? You don't cut down nut trees to harvest the nuts do you.
I have to admit I haven't taped very many trees, and I am sure there is an art that works best. However how many years does it take to grow a tree to harvest age?
Old tires aren't just used for door mats any more.
Taping a tree is not harvesting the latex? Since when is cutting down a plant the only way to harvest a crop? You don't cut down nut trees to harvest the nuts do you.
I have to admit I haven't taped very many trees, and I am sure there is an art that works best. However how many years does it take to grow a tree to harvest age?
- Thread starter
- #20
I see it as rubber trees don't grow everywhere, but dandelions do seem to grow in more places so it should allow for more production of natural rubber. Also I would think dandelions would be easer to automate the production and latex extraction which would make natural rubber less expencive. Sorry for the poor people taping trees now.
The next question would be if there would be quality differences, like there is between natural rubber and man-made rubber (or natural and natural rubbers).
I would also think with dandelions that crop rotation would be possible, allowing a farmer to change to a crop that maybe more needed next year.
The next question would be if there would be quality differences, like there is between natural rubber and man-made rubber (or natural and natural rubbers).
I would also think with dandelions that crop rotation would be possible, allowing a farmer to change to a crop that maybe more needed next year.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question
- Locked
- Question
- Locked
- Question