I think the steel is coming to you in the normalized condition. The hardness you report would be very low for a quenched-and-tempered 4140.
The maximum hardness in a quenched steel depends on the carbon content of the martensite formed during the quench. The technical literature says that this maximum for an xx40 steel is HRC 60 --- before tempering. And, since 4140 is not a deep hardening steel, this hardness will be only on the surface and --- depending on the mass of the part --- a short distance below. After tempering --- almost always a very good idea --- at a temperature of 150C, you should expect to have (at the surface) a 0.2% yield strength of about 1460 MPa, an ultimate tensile strength of about 1970 MPa, an elongation to plastic instability of a little over 5%, a total elongation of something between 10 and 14%, and an HRC of 54.
You may have to re-think your choice of material.