Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Fco expression ? 1
- Thread starter rb1957
- Start date
Mil-Hdbk-5"C" should be your first hint that this has gone by the wayside.
It looks more like an empirical formula than some kind of exact one.
Is this for working out the transition from elastic to plastic buckling of long columns?
Does the end of the chapter have references to the source of this calc?
STF
It looks more like an empirical formula than some kind of exact one.
Is this for working out the transition from elastic to plastic buckling of long columns?
Does the end of the chapter have references to the source of this calc?
STF
SWComposites
Aerospace
Off top of my head it is probably the short column Johnson-Euler column stability cutoff value.
-
1
- #4
Fco is a parameter is the empirical column buckling curve used for "short" columns. For long columns, Euler's formula applies. For short columns, plasticity is a factor, and empirical formulas are often used. I think the more "modern" aerospace approach would use Euler's equation with the Tangent Modulus, where long or short is automatically included.
The transitional L'/rho value referred to is the transition between long & short columns. If your L'/rho is greater, you have a long column, which is evidently the case the author had, and you can use Euler's formula. Since he had a "long" column the author does not go on to show the short column formula, which would be a linear function of L'/rho containing Fco. The Johnson-Euler formula is another empirical short column formula. It is parabolic and is often used for steels, whereas a linear short column formula is often used for aluminum alloys.
I do not have a copy of MIL-HDBK-5C to confirm this. Newer versions of MIL-HDBK-5 do not seem to have these formulas. Similar (or identical?) equations appear in Bruhn, chapter C4.5 titled "Column formulas for aluminum alloy tubes". He gives different forms of the equations depending on the exact alloy.
The transitional L'/rho value referred to is the transition between long & short columns. If your L'/rho is greater, you have a long column, which is evidently the case the author had, and you can use Euler's formula. Since he had a "long" column the author does not go on to show the short column formula, which would be a linear function of L'/rho containing Fco. The Johnson-Euler formula is another empirical short column formula. It is parabolic and is often used for steels, whereas a linear short column formula is often used for aluminum alloys.
I do not have a copy of MIL-HDBK-5C to confirm this. Newer versions of MIL-HDBK-5 do not seem to have these formulas. Similar (or identical?) equations appear in Bruhn, chapter C4.5 titled "Column formulas for aluminum alloy tubes". He gives different forms of the equations depending on the exact alloy.
- Thread starter
- #5
- Status