Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

ETABS: Automatic Live Load Reduction 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

StructuralAddict

Civil/Environmental
Jul 19, 2016
106
Hi All,

I am modeling a sample project to understand how ETABS reduces the live load automatically.

I modeled the 10-storey building shown in the attached file by defining the live load pattern one time as (Live) and the other time as (Reducible Live) from "Define --> Load Patterns..."

I also chose the Canadian Building Code (NBCC2010) from "Design --> Live Load Reduction Factors... --> Tributary Area (Based on Design Code)".

I assumed that the live load on the slabs is 2.873 kPa and the span between each two adjacent columns is 6.0 m. Dead load is not considered in the analysis (Self-weight multiplier = 0).

Surprisingly, the results for both cases (live and reducible live) are the same! This means that ETABS did not reduce the live load as it should do.

Can anyone please help me with this issue? What should I do to let ETABS consider the live load reduction?

Thanks in advance!

Monir
 
 http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=ac524dee-45d7-4cba-ac35-87c4d1c42503&file=ETABS.png
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

ETABS does not reduce live load until you run a design. If you're just looking at plain analysis results, your live load reduction won't be in there yet.

If you're looking at tables, the table that would have live load reduction incorporated is Tables>Design>Design Forces. It will also only give you results for load combinations that are designated for design, not individual load cases.
 
Thank you MrHershey, you are right! I checked the design forces and they were reduced as expected. I made a quick comparison between ETABS results and manual calculations for the reduction factor:

Reduction Factors (ETABS):
Story 10: 0.832
Story 9: 0.683
Story 8: 0.613
Story 7: 0.571
Story 6: 0.542
Story 5: 0.520
Story 4: 0.503
Story 3: 0.488
Story 2: 0.476
Story 1: 0.466

Reduction Factors (Manual Calculations):
Story 10: 0.822
Story 9: 0.669
Story 8: 0.601
Story 7: 0.561
Story 6: 0.533
Story 5: 0.513
Story 4: 0.497
Story 3: 0.484
Story 2: 0.474
Story 1: 0.465



 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor