Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Communicaing through steel
- Thread starter emseezed
- Start date
MacGyverS2000
Electrical
Absolutely... hand me a hammer and I'll knock out morse code until my arm tires.
Dan - Owner
Dan - Owner
- Thread starter
- #3
MacGyverS2000
Electrical
In what condition is the vessel located (i.e., is it at the bottom of the ocean, in the middle of the desert, etc.)? Do you have line of sight? What data rate do you require?
You'll need an external antenna... trying to broadcast internally through a steel sheet would require enough power to cook the occupants.
Dan - Owner
You'll need an external antenna... trying to broadcast internally through a steel sheet would require enough power to cook the occupants.
Dan - Owner
- Thread starter
- #5
Thanks for your response.It is actually on a factory floor.Line of sight from inside is doubtful. From your response
what we will probably do is have a portable transmitter
on each worker transmitting to a central station inside the enclosure - that connected to an external antenna transmitting to a remote data station.
I am not that familiar with radio my backround is more electrical engineering but would it be possible to use the
Steel vessel as an antenna or would that be impractical
what we will probably do is have a portable transmitter
on each worker transmitting to a central station inside the enclosure - that connected to an external antenna transmitting to a remote data station.
I am not that familiar with radio my backround is more electrical engineering but would it be possible to use the
Steel vessel as an antenna or would that be impractical
There are probably some rules (OSHA or local equivalent) that might require that the access hatch be left open and that the people inside be wearing a safety harnesses (not so much for falling, but so that if they collapse, someone can pull them out without entering the space themselves).
If these assumptions are true, then it wouldn't be difficult to provide them with walkie-talkies (the usual sort with BNC antenna jacks on top) and long antenna extension cables running outside (tied to the harness) to some external magnet mount antennas. All of this gear is readily available and off-the-shelf.
If these assumptions are true, then it wouldn't be difficult to provide them with walkie-talkies (the usual sort with BNC antenna jacks on top) and long antenna extension cables running outside (tied to the harness) to some external magnet mount antennas. All of this gear is readily available and off-the-shelf.
robertjo24
Industrial
You can have reliable communications by installing a WLAN repeater, sometimes referred to as a range extender by some companies. Istall the repeater on this inside, run an antenna external to the enclosure.
There are passive repeaters, (basically two back to back antennas connected together), but they are not really going to help.
There are passive repeaters, (basically two back to back antennas connected together), but they are not really going to help.
- Thread starter
- #9
Hi Robert Thanks for your response - great idea according to my research Wlan repeaters are specifically for extending
the wireless capability of wireless internet to laptops pdas and the like.I am going to be using industrial grade data transmitters and recievers dont think wlan repeaters be able to be integrated in such a system.But if it can be done - I would be happy to hear how.
the wireless capability of wireless internet to laptops pdas and the like.I am going to be using industrial grade data transmitters and recievers dont think wlan repeaters be able to be integrated in such a system.But if it can be done - I would be happy to hear how.
robertjo24
Industrial
The other option, although more cost, woule be to place a client/device side radio on the exterior, connected to an AP radio on the interior to build your own repeater.
We do this with the inductrial radios to get over and around large obstructions, and will work in your situation.
We do this with the inductrial radios to get over and around large obstructions, and will work in your situation.
Shifting from radiation to conduction may lead to an answer. Coupling the antennas to the steel shell and by a copper conductor cable from outside steel to monitoring/transcieve location point may work beyond your expectations... ralph g. GerwingR Vancouver Metro BC.Ca
I haven't a mechanical background, though I guess vessels should include some quartz, templated glass windows, or at least small light pipes of some suitable design for optical communications through the walls.
Doors could also be electrically isolated from the vessel wall, forming a 2nd conductor(wall to ground). Communication devices could take power while passing messages through the door.
Regards,
Gonzalo
Doors could also be electrically isolated from the vessel wall, forming a 2nd conductor(wall to ground). Communication devices could take power while passing messages through the door.
Regards,
Gonzalo
I specialise in providing RF solutions in confined spaces such as tunnels and underground stations. Most systems use radiating cables or antennas within the confined space linked to a base station or repeater. A relatively small space could be covered by a single antenna, although more complex areas may require several. Much will depend on the frequency of operation and the power budgets. Can you provide any more information regarding the frequency of operation, transmitter power and the size of the area to be covered? Can you run cables into the steeel vessel?
- Status