P1ENG
Structural
- Aug 25, 2010
- 237
I have to check a canopy going to Chicago. It is less than 200' so the lateral MWFRS wind pressure from column A is 20 psf. It is an open structure, so the uplift is 100% of that value [20 psf]. It is basically just a parapet, so the lateral force is 200% of that value [40 psf]. This is MUCH greater than if I calculated the wind pressures per ASCE 7. So, the question is, are these the values that replace net pressures of ASCE 7 (1.0W ASCE 7-05; 0.6W ASCE 7-10}, effectively making them my ASD wind pressures? They don't get factored somehow? I am using the 14th edition SCM to check my steel, not the super old whatever is referenced. It would take too much time to "downgrade" my calculation template for the occasional Chicago project. So annoying; if ASCE 7 is good enough for CA (high seismic), FL (high wind), and Minnesota (high snow), it should be good enough for Chicago which is moderate in all of these!
Juston Fluckey, SE, PE, AWS CWI
Engineering Consultant
Juston Fluckey, SE, PE, AWS CWI
Engineering Consultant