Actually, we are the utility. We have always used a rule of thumb of 20 feet minimum, but this case is a little different. There is plenty of solid limestone here and the contractor has been beating and pecking the heck out of it for over a month. It has gotten so bad that he was only laying one stick of pipe a day. It was taking the rock trencher almost 8 hours to get to 5 feet. He has hired a special blast contractor to come in and test to see if the method will work. The company is Nonex Systems and they claim they can blast right up to the edge of the force main trench and not disturb it. Even claiming that a seismograph would not pick up the detonation. I am witnessing the test today so I will try to post what I see later.