Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Alternative for HCL in ion-exchange resin 1
- Thread starter MTFC
- Start date
- Status
-
1
- #2
H2SO4
but you state demineralisation. do you mean de-ioniation? some sites use the words interchangeably but i was taught that de-mineralized water was made using salt and to exchange sodium for calcium in the water.
not sure about food industry but to make high purity water for boilers over 600 psig, we would use sulfuric acid and sodium hydroxide for our cation and anion resins.
you should ask your water treatment consultants or resin suppliers.
but you state demineralisation. do you mean de-ioniation? some sites use the words interchangeably but i was taught that de-mineralized water was made using salt and to exchange sodium for calcium in the water.
not sure about food industry but to make high purity water for boilers over 600 psig, we would use sulfuric acid and sodium hydroxide for our cation and anion resins.
you should ask your water treatment consultants or resin suppliers.
Like BenThayer said, "you should ask you water treatment consultants or resin suppliers".
In addition, you should keep a few things in mind:
1. HCl is a more efficient regenerant than sulfuric acid, resulting in higher resin capacities and lower sodium leakage.
2. Unless you are treating soft water, sulfuric acid will result in the creation of calcium sulfate. The regeneration process/sequence will need to be modified to allow for a step-wise introduction of the acid to prevent the formation of calcium sulfate precipitate in the resin bed. This will require some piping and valving changes, the extent will depend on the method used for the introduction of the acid (eductor or pump).
3. If your cation uses a separate acid distributor, it will most likely be necessary to examine the lateral hole sizing, based on the new acid flow rates, to maintain an even flow distribution.
Anyway, just some random thoughts for. your consideration.
In addition, you should keep a few things in mind:
1. HCl is a more efficient regenerant than sulfuric acid, resulting in higher resin capacities and lower sodium leakage.
2. Unless you are treating soft water, sulfuric acid will result in the creation of calcium sulfate. The regeneration process/sequence will need to be modified to allow for a step-wise introduction of the acid to prevent the formation of calcium sulfate precipitate in the resin bed. This will require some piping and valving changes, the extent will depend on the method used for the introduction of the acid (eductor or pump).
3. If your cation uses a separate acid distributor, it will most likely be necessary to examine the lateral hole sizing, based on the new acid flow rates, to maintain an even flow distribution.
Anyway, just some random thoughts for. your consideration.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question
