Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

Register Log in
  • Congratulations JAE on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. Flotsam7018

    IEBC Allowable 5% Gravity Increase on Total Load or Load Type?

    Simply that an increase below the 5% threshold for all (3) load cases can result in a greater stress increase than 5% or more for a single load case. I agree and have only expressed the same interpretation throughout this thread - no argument from me.
  2. Flotsam7018

    Welded together baseplate

    Even most small fab shops these days have a plasma table, so I wouldn’t worry about an L-shaped plate. In fact, I would prefer it. CJP welding two thick plates is more work and controlling distortion of the plate can be quite a challenge.
  3. Flotsam7018

    IEBC Allowable 5% Gravity Increase on Total Load or Load Type?

    Our interpretation is the same - see my initial response, but clearly others have a different take. And what if you have a 4.9% increase in dead, live and snow on a member subject to all (3) load cases?
  4. Flotsam7018

    IEBC Allowable 5% Gravity Increase on Total Load or Load Type?

    The removal of the 5% stress increase isn't the root of the confusion, but rather the language change from gravity loads to dead, live or snow. I disagree; it is clearly...not clear. See above. The goal isn't to sidestep any requirements but to reflect the code adopted level of risk and extend...
  5. Flotsam7018

    Residential- Curved Stud Walls

    It certainly can work as @phamENG indicated but is well outside the IRC and would require some creativity even for an engineered design. But that's where the fun is, no? My first thought would be to take a Riemann sum type of approach in which you would subdivide the curve into straight wall...
  6. Flotsam7018

    IEBC Allowable 5% Gravity Increase on Total Load or Load Type?

    Yes - you must become one with your inner lawyer when it comes to the IEBC. I'm going to go against the consensus so far and say that my interpretation of the 2021 IEBC is for each load case (not sure I completely agree with that, but that is how it reads). The 2015 IEBC was clear this exception...
  7. Flotsam7018

    Welding Heat

    Results will very much depend on the weldment and resulting heat input. For larger weldments a WPS will be key as @r6155 eludes to in order to keep interpass temperatures within an acceptable range, what that range is will be your job to determine.
  8. Flotsam7018

    Crazy cantilevered steel deck

    Moments are resolved through baseplate connections all the time with much larger loads, if properly designed and detailed - no problem. Plus, you can make the arch happy with the drainage/thermal break detailing aspects which would be obliterated with a backspan beam into the floor framing.
  9. Flotsam7018

    Crazy cantilevered steel deck

    I’d prefer the joists to simple span to the front edge beam and cantilever an edge beam off the HSS post at each end. That may prove tricky to meet the arch’s minimal depth at the front edge though. Hopefully there’s some blocking or something for the center handrail post at the edges behind...
  10. Flotsam7018

    Vertically stepped wood diaphragm

    Yes. I made the gross assumption that there was a VLFR element somewhere under the wall the shear would be dragged into. If it’s truly to act as a single diaphragm I’d likely first try and do as @JAE suggests, but the trades usually hate that idea.
  11. Flotsam7018

    Vertically stepped wood diaphragm

    Seems overly complicated, but I assume you have some very high shear demand with those details. Typically, I just fasten the blocking between the truss top chords to the wall studs and feel that adequately spreads the low roof shear into the attaching wall. As for hold downs, I imagine the shear...
  12. Flotsam7018

    Simple yield line question

    YLA is general has been most useful for me for existing evaluation or construction mishaps in which you can have a chance to save the day.
  13. Flotsam7018

    Wooden Sleeper Load Distribution

    If the sleeper is relatively much stiffer than the existing joists the idea can work to spread the load out - a 4x8 probably won't cut it. If you can go with a deeper SCL beam or steel, that could get you there.
  14. Flotsam7018

    Simple yield line question

    As @BAretired mentions, for steel it's easier as your yield moment is always the same along all lines. For most typical connections the controlling yield lines are also pretty well established. Design guide 16, some new equations in the manual for out-of-plane loads on HSS walls are all based on...
  15. Flotsam7018

    Thickened Edge Slab Analysis

    I calculate the tension in my slab bars to balance the eccentricity of the haunch, then proportion the flexural capacity of the slab based on the equivalent moment.
  16. Flotsam7018

    Career Advice – Design Experience Getting Offshored

    This is depressing. Coupled with AI coming down the pike, the future of the industry looks bleak from here. My only suggestion is to work for a small firm. I think they'll maintain their resilience against these pressures much longer than the big dogs and who knows, maybe you'll make it to...
  17. Flotsam7018

    How to fix this?

    I’d say you have a troll lurking out there. Take it as a compliment. That's an interesting take. I think you've misplaced the role of risk in our profession. Risk is an inherent part of our work and to excel you need to be comfortable with that. But risk shouldn't be viewed as a leveraging...
  18. Flotsam7018

    HOT TUB - gut check

    Nope, the hanger is the anode in this scenario. My understanding is that if the cathode to anode ratio is small, such as the case with an HDG hanger and stainless nails, you’re not going to rust out the hanger unless in an extreme environment. If the materials were reversed, yeah - bad news.
  19. Flotsam7018

    How to fix this?

    Passing what? Would it hold the load for some arbitrary amount of time, yeah probably. Job done? Could there be issues that lead to a lesser than intended performance, excessive nail slip (for the lucky few that made it into the hanger) for instance? Perhaps. I don’t know how you could possibly...
  20. Flotsam7018

    Steel Beam to Wood Post Connection

    I love this detail when crushing isn’t a problem, as opposed to terminating the top plates for a direct column connection and strapping across the beam, assuming there’s axial in the plates. I would fasten the bottom flange to the top plates as you show, but honestly feel there’s plenty of...

Part and Inventory Search

Back
Top