Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by TonyES

  1. TonyES

    Cable Bracing for a Deck

    I'm engineering a deck that is designed independent of the building with cables in the "X" formation designed as tension only cables for the lateral system. The cables are attached to plates that are bolted to wood posts and wood beams. I designed the lateral system with an R of 1.5. Table...
  2. TonyES

    Min Pile Embed for building over water

    Thanks everyone. I have expressed these concerns to the client and hope he'll reconsider hiring this guy. I've requested hard data to confirm. He has not submitted any reports yet but I'll make sure to review them.
  3. TonyES

    Min Pile Embed for building over water

    I have a client that drove about 50 10" diameter piles along their water front property and now want to build a two story boathouse on it. They were driven 6-8' into the soil with a 4500lb drop hammer. They stick above the soil about 15 feet, than there is a dock and above the dock is a two...
  4. TonyES

    Sill plate on foundation - lack of full bearing

    We have a 12" thick wood framed wall which structurally only needs to be a 2x6 wall but due to desired insulation values the architect is wanting them as 12 inches thick. The contractor does not want to pour a 12" thick concrete wall, rather he wants to do an 8" ICF wall with 2" of insulation...
  5. TonyES

    Insulation between Metal Deck and Purlins

    The contractor says he'll save over $200,000 by doing it this way but I don't see it. Either way I agree with the comments and appreciate the responses.
  6. TonyES

    Insulation between Metal Deck and Purlins

    For some thermal break issues the contractor wants to install a 1" thick layer of insulation on top of metal purlins and than screw down the 1.5" 20g metal deck on top of the insulation. This is for a large tilt up concrete building with steel girders every 20' and metal purlins spanning the...
  7. TonyES

    Water Tank Slab Joints

    I am looking for some assistance on slab / foundation joints for use in a water tank. The tank wall has 12” cast-in-place concrete walls with an ID of 30’. I currently show a thickened continuous ftg that is 6’-6” wide x 1’-0” thk transitioning at a 3H to 1 V slope to a 6” slab (all poured at...
  8. TonyES

    CMU Cracks Structurally a Concern?

    Mike: the geotech did consider uplift and I agree that 6" may not suffice, we will recommend more, in fact we have to have something there else the soil around will just cave in so 12" of some compressible material should work. haynewp: I just joined this project and I think it was the...
  9. TonyES

    CMU Cracks Structurally a Concern?

    The quick question: when do cracks in a cmu wall become a structural concern? Most posts I viewed deal with the cause of the cracks. Once that cause has been determined and fixed than when is the building structurally in jeopardy? I'm not thinking about minor shrinkage cracks but larger...
  10. TonyES

    Snow guards (Sno-Fence) on large metal building - worth it?

    I would install them especially if the building is tall, imagine snow falling 20' before hitting a child. They would also help you in a legal case because at least you did something to prevent injury. They do work too - I live in a snowy area and they do work, if the building is heated than...
  11. TonyES

    Thru Bolts in CMU Wall

    The lack of information does make it difficult to properly understand as well as Engineer anything. I don't have and won't have any idea where they might place this connection so I'm going to have to find the worst case condition and assume. It is actually a double CMU wall so two 8 inch walls...
  12. TonyES

    Thru Bolts in CMU Wall

    I've searched many previous threads on this subject but unable to find a solution. I want to put a bolt through a CMU wall (a grouted and an ungrouted case) and a plate and nut on the outside face. It is to hold a cable that will be in tension. Does anyone know how to put a capacity to this...
  13. TonyES

    Why did the Control Joints not work?

    I should've had more restraint and not allowed the contractor to change the original design from separate footings to monolithic. Hind sight is 20-20. by the way, the PEMB calcs have zero thrust on those footings - all the thrust was designed to go to the exterior columns. Even though during...
  14. TonyES

    Why did the Control Joints not work?

    Yes the first cracks appeared two months or so before the roof. I measured the CJ and they were 1.5" deep, plans called out d/4 (5" slab). There was no fiber or mesh, rather #4 @ 18" ocew continuous through the CJ's. I've never seen slabs that stop the reinforcement from going through a...
  15. TonyES

    Why did the Control Joints not work?

    The contractor said that they were cut "very quickly" after they poured, that was my first question to him. The plans state within 10 hours of placement. I have no way of verifing this time though. I would typically expect the cracks to occur at the thinnest section, with a 8' square footing...

Part and Inventory Search