Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

Register Log in
  • Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by RGCook

  1. RGCook

    Compressible Flow Sudden Contraction

    I have saturated air (with water) flowing in a large duct at a nominal 1 ft/sec velocity. There is a sudden contraction such that the velocity becomes 45 ft/sec in the duct and the flow continues on inside the smaller duct for a long distance (not a nozzle). I am wondering how I calculate what...
  2. RGCook

    Debunking the Control Architectures

    Thanks for your helpful response guys. An EI&C friend recently told me to stick with HART as well. We did put three Micromotion coriolis on Modbus in the last plant but I think we will hold the line and see how it goes. Appreciate the input. Bob
  3. RGCook

    ISA symbol for Coriolis flow meter

    You can also use the symbol for a magmeter and instead of putting an "M" in the box, put a "C". Then update your P&ID lead sheet in case someone doesn't understand.
  4. RGCook

    Debunking the Control Architectures

    What I mean is...why so many architectures and "open" standards. I didn't even mention DeviceNet or others that I am not even aware of. Perhaps Debunk is a harsh word. But I am really trying to understand which ones merit investigation and which ones are just "piling on".
  5. RGCook

    Debunking the Control Architectures

    Can anyone point me to a good reference that describes and debunks the various architectures currently in use for control systems. In particular, I am interesting in learning more about the following: 1. Analog (4-20ma) and Discrete IO versus 2. ModBus TCP/IP versus 3. Profibus, versus 4...
  6. RGCook

    316L Vessel Cracks near welds

    Folks, Our corrosion expert has inspected the tank. A piece is being removed for testing. His first thought is carbide depletion SCC and, as stanweld suggested, many of the cracks appear to have originated from OUTSIDE the tank. On removal of the insulation (simply 2" of fiberglass with...
  7. RGCook

    316L Vessel Cracks near welds

    stanweld and EdStainless, Interesting points about potential for external origination. That is very possible since the original leak ran down the sides of the tank and dried salt can be seen in many areas. We are proceeding with expert analysis. I will keep the group posted. In my research, I...
  8. RGCook

    316L Vessel Cracks near welds

    hacksaw and metengr: Thank you both for your insight and reference. The solution treated varies but generally consists of extremely high (saturated) levels of sodium sulfate and some sodium chloride, although generally the chlorides are below 100 mg/L. The vessel is 316 and NOT 316L as I...
  9. RGCook

    316L Vessel Cracks near welds

    Hello, I am a chemical engineer with no materials science expertise. I have a problem with a 10,000 gallon 316 Stainless steel reactor. It is 10' diameter with ASME heads top and bottom. This may sound strange but the vessel normally runs with only 12 inches of liquid (sidewall depth). I sparge...
  10. RGCook

    soda regeneration from sodium sulphate

    To determine if an aqueous phase inorganic precipitation reaction will proceed, look at the solubility of the reagents vs. the products (as a rule). In this example, you have sodium sulfate that is very soluble and lime (very, very insoluble)...can't recall the solubility off the top of my head...
  11. RGCook

    Flowmeters on demineralised water application

    Don't leave out transit time in your evaluation.
  12. RGCook

    Eporting Excel to a Database Application

    bpeirson, As mentioned, Access will easily import your data into a database that has tables representing proper normalization of the system data. You may need to pick up a good book on Access to appreciate this, but in the process of pulling your data into Access, it is best to pull in the...
  13. RGCook

    P&ID Information

    cornejoi, Your response was very helpful. I would like to see the use of Interlock numbers you reference in your reply. I have not seen such a thing on P&IDs before. If possible to send a P&ID illustrating this concept? I would be very grateful. Bob Cook
  14. RGCook

    Multi Effect Evaporator Plant with Flash MX

    MVD, That is very good work. Well done!
  15. RGCook

    Improving color in water

    A possible solution is to bleach the color out. Run some trials with sodium hypochlorite. If possible, use at pH 5-7 (slightly acidic). You don't seem to understand the nature of your water, hence the general reply. Good luck.
See more

Part and Inventory Search

Back
Top