Eng-Tips is the largest forum for Engineering Professionals on the Internet.

Members share and learn making Eng-Tips Forums the best source of engineering information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations dmapguru on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Air Entrainment 1

Klunker1

Structural
Joined
Aug 1, 2025
Messages
4
Hi All!
Something I've never had to do so a little lost on who is responsible. I'm specifying a concrete mis with 6% air entrainment but the batch plant is only offering a mix of 2% and won't provide an air entrainment add mix design. The concrete contractor says he won't add a the mix in the field without guidance and testing. I can get the testing done on site by a 3rd party inspector, but can I expect the inspector to give direction on how much admix to use? Would this fall back on me as the SEOR? Thanks in advance!
 
Do a mix design and run trials with the batch plant. I think you have a communication issue since most ares require 6% air if exposure in the area requires it. You are leaving out information.
 
Hi All!
Something I've never had to do so a little lost on who is responsible. I'm specifying a concrete mis with 6% air entrainment but the batch plant is only offering a mix of 2% and won't provide an air entrainment add mix design. The concrete contractor says he won't add a the mix in the field without guidance and testing. I can get the testing done on site by a 3rd party inspector, but can I expect the inspector to give direction on how much admix to use? Would this fall back on me as the SEOR? Thanks in advance!
It's interesting how the concrete supplier is "offering" 2% air. This is entrapped air that is probably naturally in the concrete. I never heard of a concrete supplier refusing to put an air entrainment admixture in the concrete when it was needed. Was a mix design submitted? I would discuss this with the GC or CM and have them force the concrete supplier to add the air. Are there any other in the concrete? If so, call the sales rep for those admixtures and have them discuss how much air to add to the mix. And then make sure the inspector tests for air
 
Do you have frost issues? If not the added air will not help, except make the concrete a little more 'workable' on site. Normally concrete without air entrainment has about 2% air, just from mixing. If you need air, then find a different supplier.
 
It's interesting how the concrete supplier is "offering" 2% air. This is entrapped air that is probably naturally in the concrete. I never heard of a concrete supplier refusing to put an air entrainment admixture in the concrete when it was needed. Was a mix design submitted? I would discuss this with the GC or CM and have them force the concrete supplier to add the air. Are there any other in the concrete? If so, call the sales rep for those admixtures and have them discuss how much air to add to the mix. And then make sure the inspector tests for air
Cliff234,
Yes mix design was submitted. I’ve never had a plant refuse to add air which is why I’m a bit confused. I’m getting some information second-hand which could be part of the confusion. Thanks.
 
Do you have frost issues? If not the added air will not help, except make the concrete a little more 'workable' on site. Normally concrete without air entrainment has about 2% air, just from mixing. If you need air, then find a different supplier.
Project is in south Texas which isn’t know for frost although they do go below freezing occasionally and the structure is fully exposed to the elements.
 
Contractor’s right to be wary. Plants tend to sell mixes that are tried and tested. Find a new plant.
 
Ive seen this type of problem in the southern US.
In my opinion, the contractor either needs to find a new concrete provider, or you need to remove the air entrained requirement. I wouldn't want to be involved in teaching a contractor how to add their own air...
 
I kind of figured it was a southern thing given the lack of freezing temps but also figured a quality batch plant would be able to provide something so standard in the industry. Agree with your comment on training, we've recommended they find another plant.
 
"Project is in south Texas which isn’t know for frost"

Freeze thaw is not likely to be an issue, then.
 

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top