Is there anyway to prove equivalence of different material from different codes ?
Is there anyway to prove equivalence of different material from different codes ?
(OP)
Hello guys,
So i've got an issue with a project, we need to find an equivalent to a material from a french code which is TU37C, because it's unavailable in the market -we have only astm material-. I've done some researches and i've found out that likes of A106 Gr A, A192.. are equivalent but the issue is that its mentioned in a table on different websites and without any codes that state that these are equivalent. So i'm asking how would you guys prove it to the client ? or if there's some code that states equivalent material from different codes (like french and american or european and american)
Thank you,
So i've got an issue with a project, we need to find an equivalent to a material from a french code which is TU37C, because it's unavailable in the market -we have only astm material-. I've done some researches and i've found out that likes of A106 Gr A, A192.. are equivalent but the issue is that its mentioned in a table on different websites and without any codes that state that these are equivalent. So i'm asking how would you guys prove it to the client ? or if there's some code that states equivalent material from different codes (like french and american or european and american)
Thank you,
Talk To Other Members
RE: Is there anyway to prove equivalence of different material from different codes ?
They will no doubt be different in some aspects, so what one really requires are the minimum properties required for the task.
If one is X tensile yield and the other is Y tensile yield and both of them exceed the required tensile yield (and factor of safety, et al,) then you are good to go.
RE: Is there anyway to prove equivalence of different material from different codes ?
Steve Jones
Corrosion Management Consultant
www.linkedin.com/in/drstevejones
All answers are personal opinions only and are in no way connected with any employer.
RE: Is there anyway to prove equivalence of different material from different codes ?
https://www.asminternational.org/
RE: Is there anyway to prove equivalence of different material from different codes ?