Beef Supreme
Mechanical
If you were tasked with selecting FEA software for your company, which one would you choose? And why?
Thank you!
Thank you!
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
FEA Software Options
- Thread starter Beef Supreme
- Start date
- Status
It depends mainly on how much the company can spend (usually in the form of an annual subscription) and what kind of problems will be solved - each software has different capabilities in terms of advanced analyses and in some cases programs are sold in the form of separate modules. Personally, I would choose Abaqus for highly nonlinear solid mechanics problems involving contact and complex material models (including fracture mechanics). But for CFD and some other types of analyses, I would vote for ANSYS. Sometimes even CAD-embedded FEA modules are enough and the company can work with SolidWorks Simulation, for example (to reduce cost and avoid buying unnecessarily advanced software). Well, in some (rather rare) cases open-source software may suffice - OpenFOAM solver's popularity is a good example.
There's an article titled "5 Tips for buying FEA Software" on Simuleon's blog - you may find something interesting there.
There's an article titled "5 Tips for buying FEA Software" on Simuleon's blog - you may find something interesting there.
GregLocock
Automotive
FWIW we've got licenses for at least 5 different FEA packages (from memory), so it is definitely a case of horses for courses.
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376
Cheers
Greg Locock
New here? Try reading these, they might help FAQ731-376
to follow up on greg's post ... it depends on what you want to do, and how much effort you're going to put in the learn it.
civil eng or other ? civil seem to have their own preferred codes (RISA, no recommendation), other will use lots of codes (ANSYS, SolidWorks, FeMap, PATRAN/NASTRAN).
simple FEA or something more colourful (dynamics, hyper-elastic, ...)
There is, IMHO, no "best" code. All should give the same answers (with the same mesh), some are easier to learn than others. The biggest difference is the pre- and post- processing.
another day in paradise, or is paradise one day closer ?
civil eng or other ? civil seem to have their own preferred codes (RISA, no recommendation), other will use lots of codes (ANSYS, SolidWorks, FeMap, PATRAN/NASTRAN).
simple FEA or something more colourful (dynamics, hyper-elastic, ...)
There is, IMHO, no "best" code. All should give the same answers (with the same mesh), some are easier to learn than others. The biggest difference is the pre- and post- processing.
another day in paradise, or is paradise one day closer ?
Beef Supreme
Most comprehensive and popular packages- Abaqus and Ansys for most mechanical products right from Pre-processing, solving and post-processing.
Based on your requirement (Your product, what you want to do CFD/FEA or combined together, just design based introductory analysis, full fledged complex analysis like crash of car, fracture mechanics, non-linear material simulation like hyper-elastic/plastic, plastics, visco-elastic/plastic etc.), there are different packages which can be used.
This link may help in shortlisting and decision making.
Most comprehensive and popular packages- Abaqus and Ansys for most mechanical products right from Pre-processing, solving and post-processing.
Based on your requirement (Your product, what you want to do CFD/FEA or combined together, just design based introductory analysis, full fledged complex analysis like crash of car, fracture mechanics, non-linear material simulation like hyper-elastic/plastic, plastics, visco-elastic/plastic etc.), there are different packages which can be used.
This link may help in shortlisting and decision making.
@Beef Supreme
This topic has been hashed and rehashed quite a number of times on this forum. Follow the discussion in these links for some perspective:
This topic has been hashed and rehashed quite a number of times on this forum. Follow the discussion in these links for some perspective:
@Beef Supreme
What software I would choose is easy. I would choose the software I have used for many years. But I think you need to ask yourself a few questions to start with.
- What is your budget?
- What are your analysis requirements? It ranges from linear static and up to non-linear dynamics including multi-physics. And there are also "side-tracks".
- How will you interact with the software, or requirements for pre/post software? Manually build a model or import a solid and auto-mesh?
My impression is that you think there is a single software that is the best for all types of applications. My experience is that there is no such software.
Good Luck
Thomas
What software I would choose is easy. I would choose the software I have used for many years. But I think you need to ask yourself a few questions to start with.
- What is your budget?
- What are your analysis requirements? It ranges from linear static and up to non-linear dynamics including multi-physics. And there are also "side-tracks".
- How will you interact with the software, or requirements for pre/post software? Manually build a model or import a solid and auto-mesh?
My impression is that you think there is a single software that is the best for all types of applications. My experience is that there is no such software.
Good Luck
Thomas
- Status
Similar threads
- Question
- Question