Using Jupyter Notebooks vs Excel for Engineering Calculations
Using Jupyter Notebooks vs Excel for Engineering Calculations
4
Connor Ferster (Structural)
(OP)
Hi all,
Over the last two years of trying to find fast and effective ways of generating engineering notes on a computer, I have developed a Python library called handcalcs that I wanted to share. It is free and open-source software.
Doing calculations in Excel can be fast and easy, however, to use a printout from an Excel sheet as engineering calculation notes, time needs to be spent formatting, typing formulas into adjacent cells, and possibly naming your cells so that your formulas are easy to debug. Now the time spent starts adding up.
handcalcs was designed to quickly render calculations on the computer similar to how you would right them by hand: First the formula, the numeric substitution, and then the result. Additionally, it will render out any comments you may like to include about your assumptions.
I have made a video showing a side-by-side comparison of creating a small calculation sheet (buckling resistance of HSS member) in Excel vs. handcalcs-on-Jupyter to show the difference.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9Uzy3Eb-XI
Wanted to share it with the engineering community with this post!
Over the last two years of trying to find fast and effective ways of generating engineering notes on a computer, I have developed a Python library called handcalcs that I wanted to share. It is free and open-source software.
Doing calculations in Excel can be fast and easy, however, to use a printout from an Excel sheet as engineering calculation notes, time needs to be spent formatting, typing formulas into adjacent cells, and possibly naming your cells so that your formulas are easy to debug. Now the time spent starts adding up.
handcalcs was designed to quickly render calculations on the computer similar to how you would right them by hand: First the formula, the numeric substitution, and then the result. Additionally, it will render out any comments you may like to include about your assumptions.
I have made a video showing a side-by-side comparison of creating a small calculation sheet (buckling resistance of HSS member) in Excel vs. handcalcs-on-Jupyter to show the difference.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9Uzy3Eb-XI
Wanted to share it with the engineering community with this post!
Talk To Other Members
RE: Using Jupyter Notebooks vs Excel for Engineering Calculations
/Peter
RE: Using Jupyter Notebooks vs Excel for Engineering Calculations
How simple would it be to get conglomerate the data from either CISC's SST excel table or AISC's v15 section properties tables into some sort of look up file? Or even the data from Appendix C in NBCC? This is kind of the big hangup for me getting started with the coding environment as opposed to using some Excel sheets I've tweaked over the years.
RE: Using Jupyter Notebooks vs Excel for Engineering Calculations
skeletron:
you can load the AISC shapes into a dictionary or list and perform the sorting/look up. I have a couple versions of the shapes database in my personal github as GUI enabled programs.
My Personal Open Source Structural Applications:
https://github.com/buddyd16/Structural-Engineering
Open Source Structural GitHub Group:
https://github.com/open-struct-engineer