×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

(OP)
In a middle-eastern refinery project, client specification calls for removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions after erection. As would be expected of contractors, they are seeking Waiver against this requirement. The reason put forth is that there is no value in removing them.

What is industry practice in this regard?

Any help would be appreciated.

Thank you.

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

I've never heard of them being removed. When the equipment eventually needs to be replaced you'll be glad they're there. Why does the client want to require removal?

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

I have specified and reviewed many ASME Vessels, heat exchangers and other components.

There is no reason to remove these lifting lugs and padeyes ...

The client must have a reason for his demands and not point to an old specification and say "It says so here !!"

MJCronin
Sr. Process Engineer

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

The only problem I can see with leaving the lugs on would be interference with vessel insulation.

"Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but they are not entitled to their own facts."

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

Or unnecessary cold spots

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

We've had equipment where trunnion and lifting lug was removed mainly because of cold insulation.

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

IMHO, I have never believed the "cold spot" justification.... In other words, its bad because I say its bad

The cost of existing lug removal and the lost of ability to easily remove the equipment at a future date FAR outweighs the additional cost of a little creative insulation work.

Why is this even a topic of discussion ???

MJCronin
Sr. Process Engineer

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

Dear MJCronin,

Completely agree with you. Many of these "Client specifications" specially in the middle-east are in need of urgent revision.

Regards.

DHURJATI SEN
Kolkata, India

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

1) If the trunnions are left installed then they should be examined before future hoisting.

2) If horizontal vessel is mounted on skid, the lifting lugs shall be cutted below of lifting hole. The skid shall be lifted with your own lugs.
Avoid lifting lugs in horizontal pressure vessel.

Regards

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

(OP)
Thanks all of you for your valuable input.

MJCronin,

This requirement comes from Shell DEP 31.22.20.31, Pressure Vessels (Amendments/supplements to ASME Section VIII Division 1 and Division 2), para 4.15.6 of Version 32, which reads:

Lifting lugs and trunnions shall be removed after erection of the vessel is complete, unless otherwise specified by the Principal. Removal shall be such that lug or trunnion is completely covered by insulation on vessels that are insulated.

That is the reason I brought it up to the notice of this forum.

It seems the majority of contributors have not applied such requirements. In fact, even I have never used this although I have worked on a Shell project in Alberta.

Thank you.

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

I would imagine removal is mainly required for mitigating CUI in insulated vessels.
I have seen quite a couple of cases were CUI was found very localized around lifting lugs as they can create areas that trap water. Additionally they quite often protrude the insulation creating ways for water to penetrate the insulation cladding.

Daniel Breyer
Inspection Engineer

http://lnkd.in/dFcQA-w

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

AK8824:

Explain the rational for this expensive removal... as you understand it

Yes, Yes ... we all understand that the ORIGIN of this removal is a spec copied from a spec copied from a spec ..

Why, in your opinion, is this necessary ???

MJCronin
Sr. Process Engineer

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

(OP)
MJCronin,

I learnt from some friends that Ear-type lifting lugs typically suffer from the problem of corrosion due to trapped water between the lug and the vessel. There are more chances of corrosion under insulation in the trunnion region. As the trunnion projects like a fin on the vessel, there will be a possibility of heat loss.

AKumar

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

I saw the lifting lugs read removed on the high temperature duct pipe from the reactor after installation. I believe it can be based on the operation experience, and justified per agreement from Engg and Mgmt, as well.

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

AK8824

You state: "the problem of corrosion due to trapped water between the lug and the vessel.".... You mean to tell me that the lug is NOT WELDED ALL AROUND ? .... This is a defective design, unlike anything in common use

I envision this as a "padeye lifting lug"

What TF are you talking about ? ... Show examples or pictures

"I learnt from some friends".... "some people told me" .... "A guy at work once told me"

Please... No mid-eastern heresay "Whatdoyathink" engineering ....

This thread is a waste of time ....


MJCronin
Sr. Process Engineer

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

Pressure Vessel Design Manual, by D. Moss 4TH Ed.
Lifting attachments may remain on the vessel after erection unless there is some process- or interference-
related issue that would necessitate their removal.


API 571
Examples of locations where CUI can occur are listed below:
1)……
.
2) Equipment designed with insulation support rings welded directly to the vessel wall (no standoff); particularly around ladder and platform clips, and lifting lugs, nozzles and stiffener rings.

Regards

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

(OP)
Hi r6155,

Thanks for quoting the reference from Pressure Vessel Design Manual, by D. Moss. 4th Ed.

In fact, I am in agreement with you and others. What is noteworthy is that the requirement of lifting lug removal was not there in Shell DEP in Version 20. But it was added in Version 32. Your post is very helpful.

Cheers!

RE: Removal of Lifting Lugs and Trunnions

I think it's probably because some site operators have ridiculous requirements in that any lift points must be certified/registered/documented and routinely checked. If you cut them off this requirement goes away.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login


Resources

White Paper - Addressing Tooling and Casting Requirements at the Design Stage
Several of the tooling and casting requirements of a part can be addressed at the design stage. If these requirements are not addressed at the design stage, lot of time is spent in design iteration when the design reaches the die caster. These design issues lead to increase in time and cost of production leading to delay in time to market and reduced profits for the organization. Download Now
White Paper - The Other Side of Design for Assembly
Assembly level constraints need to be satisfied before the design can move downstream. This white paper will go through the various assembly level issues, which need to be tackled by various organizations on a regular basis. Know more about DFMPro, a design for assembly software. Download Now

Close Box

Join Eng-Tips® Today!

Join your peers on the Internet's largest technical engineering professional community.
It's easy to join and it's free.

Here's Why Members Love Eng-Tips Forums:

Register now while it's still free!

Already a member? Close this window and log in.

Join Us             Close