Client has requested repair of existing column (top two floors ~20 feet) at facade of building on Upper West Side in NYC. (See attached photo). Column consists of two (2) channels with lattice bars. The bars are severely corroded, as are the flanges of the channels. The web has about ~50% section loss, but we won't know for sure how much steel is left until we clean the steel. The spacing between the channels is approx. 4". Since we cannot weld to the flanges, any recommendations or suggestions on reinforcing or replacing this column as well as repairing the connection of the spandrel beam to the column? Thank you.
Are the columns and beams healthy below the repair levels? Are they weldable below the repair levels? If so perhaps you could install new columns slightly to the foreground of the existing ones for the top two stories. Then, once you hit healthy material, reinforce the beam and beam-column connection to transfer the load back to the original columns.
I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.
I've used modern channel sections fitted inside the lattice set, and welded to each other, with bolting through existing to new. The problem with this kind of deterioration is that you must work around the existing connections, and the new hybrid system must then all work together.
Have you thought about concrete encasement? Your building may not like the additional mass, but it is a potentially very effective and simple repair. Clean the existing steel, provide new bars and stirrups, pour new columns.
If you are dealing with a heritage condition you may find your situation further complicated by what will be acceptable to the HAHJ.
Oh, and though I have not done so myself, I am told that pressure grouting with non-shrink product (such as Sika 212, or more likely for this case, Sika 08 SCC) is an effective way to go as well... But I have a hard time picturing a pressure grouting not blowing out or having grout flow everywhere.
Looking at your conditions, I really think full replacement or concrete encasement are the best options. Potentially add a cathodic protection system to arrest the corrosion as well.
Please investigate all of the lower floors. I have a hard time believing that such advanced corrosion is confined to the top two floors, which I presume are the ones which were exposed during other works.
One more thing: Be very careful in your assessment of the deterioration. While widespread, it is not immediately obvious to me that the extent of corrosion is problematic. Keep in mind that the rust is nine to twelve times thicker than the base metal it replaced, thus you may not yet have a problem. As you say, quite rightly, you'll only know where you stand after a good cleaning.
I personally like to clear an extensive area to "free from lose" condition, and several localized areas to white steel prior to the final evaluation... Widespread deep pitting can be quite shocking in these situations, and can also make it very hard to get a good estimate of the net area of remaining base steel.
Red Flag Submitted
Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts. The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.
Reply To This Thread
Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.
When it comes to using an FDM 3D printer effectively and efficiently, choosing the right material at the right time is essential. This 3D Printing Materials Guide will help give you and your team a basic understanding of some FDM 3D printing polymers and composites, their strengths and weaknesses, and when to use them. Download Now
Simcenter STAR-CCM+ makes simulation accessible to process engineers with limited simulation experience but strong process knowledge. This flood of knowledge and skills will make the industry more cost efficient, less polluting and ultimately more innovative. Download Now
The need to reduce exploration and development costs has never been more important to the future of the oil and gas industry. In this special report we present how engineers and scientists from leading oil and gas companies are deploying Siemens’ simulation software in the design and operation of a range of oil and gas products and systems. Download Now
Customized products are more compelling to customers and drive higher profitability. This engineer-to-order (ETO) study finds that some companies have found better ways to design custom products, alleviating the engineering bottleneck created in most companies when quotes requests or orders roll in. Download Now
Talk To Other Members
RE: Built-Up Lattice Column Repair
I like to debate structural engineering theory -- a lot. If I challenge you on something, know that I'm doing so because I respect your opinion enough to either change it or adopt it.
RE: Built-Up Lattice Column Repair
Have you thought about concrete encasement? Your building may not like the additional mass, but it is a potentially very effective and simple repair. Clean the existing steel, provide new bars and stirrups, pour new columns.
If you are dealing with a heritage condition you may find your situation further complicated by what will be acceptable to the HAHJ.
RE: Built-Up Lattice Column Repair
Looking at your conditions, I really think full replacement or concrete encasement are the best options. Potentially add a cathodic protection system to arrest the corrosion as well.
Please investigate all of the lower floors. I have a hard time believing that such advanced corrosion is confined to the top two floors, which I presume are the ones which were exposed during other works.
RE: Built-Up Lattice Column Repair
I personally like to clear an extensive area to "free from lose" condition, and several localized areas to white steel prior to the final evaluation... Widespread deep pitting can be quite shocking in these situations, and can also make it very hard to get a good estimate of the net area of remaining base steel.