LEM vs FEM
LEM vs FEM
(OP)
hi all,
as we know LEM (limit Equilibrium Method) as one of ways to define SF on Slope Stability Analysis (Bishop, Janbu, Fellenius, Spencer, Sarma), and currently we also know FEM (Finite Element Method to define SF on Slope Stability Analyis, as my limited of experience about both of this method, here's the question :
1. could anyone to explain what are the fundamental differences between this both method?
2. how about the difference of SF if we do analysis with LEM and FEM? is the difference of SF still reliable (around 5%)?
3. what is your prefer method in design LEM and FEM? and why?
thanks in advanced,
as we know LEM (limit Equilibrium Method) as one of ways to define SF on Slope Stability Analysis (Bishop, Janbu, Fellenius, Spencer, Sarma), and currently we also know FEM (Finite Element Method to define SF on Slope Stability Analyis, as my limited of experience about both of this method, here's the question :
1. could anyone to explain what are the fundamental differences between this both method?
2. how about the difference of SF if we do analysis with LEM and FEM? is the difference of SF still reliable (around 5%)?
3. what is your prefer method in design LEM and FEM? and why?
thanks in advanced,
M.A.
RE: LEM vs FEM
2. See the paper by Griffiths and Lane on "Slope stability analysis by finite elements", Geotechnique 49, no. 3. I'm more confident in getting comparible results where the models do not contain structural elements than when they do. I say this because the introduction of structural elements can lead to differing failure mechanisms.
3. LEM tools have been developed for practicing engineers and you can find these that make setting up and running a model quick and relatively easy (perhaps too easy where non-geotech engineers can do this - but that's another subject). The FEM software that I'm familiar with doesn't have all the bells and whistle's as the LEM software and it takes me longer to create and run the model I want. I use the LEM for normal slope stability problems and move to the FEM method for complex or SSI type problems or where I want to verify uncertain results from a LEM analysis. Even with the FEM models it's wise to check with a LEM model for similar failure mechanisms. This is similar to checking one LEM analysis using another LEM software. In other words, I use both but the FEM is not routine for me for slope stability.
RE: LEM vs FEM
M.A.