Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
(OP)
Hello,
I am performing Tank re-rates and basic API-650/653 calculations for clients along the Gulf Coast. Almost all of the clients have a Hurricane preparedness procedure that involves filling their tanks to a recommended liquid level to provide overturning stability and additional stiffness to counteract the possibility of an elevated external pressure situation. I have developed a nice spreadsheet that takes care of most of this but I am now trying to incorporate this "Additional" liquid level calculation so I can recommend an liquid level to clients.
The second overturning condition of API-650 uses the M(f) term for fluid weight and determines the maximum liquid hold down moment based on a band of fluid a certain distance inward from the wall. I understand that this is supposed to account for the fact that the floor plate is relatively weak and acts as a membrane and after a certain point will begin to diaphragm thereby lifting the tank.
I have been instructed to just add the weight of the additional liquid level directly to the dead load and I believe this to be incorrect.
My question for you is: How can I correctly take into account additional liquid level to combat overturning ?
Thank You in advance for any input...
I am performing Tank re-rates and basic API-650/653 calculations for clients along the Gulf Coast. Almost all of the clients have a Hurricane preparedness procedure that involves filling their tanks to a recommended liquid level to provide overturning stability and additional stiffness to counteract the possibility of an elevated external pressure situation. I have developed a nice spreadsheet that takes care of most of this but I am now trying to incorporate this "Additional" liquid level calculation so I can recommend an liquid level to clients.
The second overturning condition of API-650 uses the M(f) term for fluid weight and determines the maximum liquid hold down moment based on a band of fluid a certain distance inward from the wall. I understand that this is supposed to account for the fact that the floor plate is relatively weak and acts as a membrane and after a certain point will begin to diaphragm thereby lifting the tank.
I have been instructed to just add the weight of the additional liquid level directly to the dead load and I believe this to be incorrect.
My question for you is: How can I correctly take into account additional liquid level to combat overturning ?
Thank You in advance for any input...





RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
Also, you can 'think outside the box' and deliberately add water to your hydrocarbon tanks if the contents are not misciable with water. A tank with a water-fill up to the top of the dike, and a few feet of oil on the oil is much easier to accomplish than finding enough oil to fill that tank full enough that a dike-full of water won't float it. Or to convince your EPA-compliance guy/gal that you REALLY need to cut notches in your tank dikes to limit the stormwater fill level.
RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...
RE: Minimum Liquid Level to Mitigate Overturning...