I've got a project repairing impact damage to a commercial carport structure. The structure was constructed circa 1980 with non-reinforced brick and mortar columns and reinforced concrete lintel beams supporting a wooden truss and shingle roof. The carport was hit by a van damaging and displacing one of the concrete lintel beams and two of the four brick columns. I am recommending replacing all columns and beams with steel members but am running into an argument from the insurance adjuster. He insists the structure should be returned to its original condition. I, however, believe a 2400' concrete lintel beam simply resting atop a brick and mortar column is an unsafe condition and should be modified to ensure there will be no catastrophic failure if another vehicle impact should occur. I am not a structural engineer and don't know the IBC inside out. Can anyone tell me if there are any code sections which would support the replacement of these members with steel members? Also, what is your opinion? Is this an unsafe condition or not?
Red Flag Submitted
Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts. The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.
Reply To This Thread
Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.
Manufacturers are at a critical juncture. Either they evolve their product processes or get disrupted by new competitors who have been built from the ground up to develop complex systems and products defined by software. Download Now
Savvy engineers have eagerly anticipated the impact of virtual reality (VR) on robot programming technology, as it can dramatically increase productivity by empowering engineers to do their jobs safer and more efficiently. Download Now