Tying into gravity sewer with gravity sewer

[Plumber John]

This might be a simple question, but I'm simple. I ran a 6" pvc gravity sanitary sewer about 80' out into the right of way where the city sewer is located. We are about 6ft deep out near our desired tie in location. The city sewer is 16 feet deep, so we are dropping 10' into an 18" clay (very old) gravity sewer line. We tapped into the top of the clay and used a product that I've not used before, then encased the connection point in concrete.

My question, since we are dropping 10' or so, is there a problem dropping straight down into the main? Our connection is a straight tee not a wye and we're going to have a cleanout access directly above the deep connection point using a wye and 45° in place of a 90 to drop down.

Any issue with that? The city engineer mentioned something about tying in at a 45° angle but that's not practical with all of the other obstructions and dangers at play.

 

[swazimatt]

The norm is to connect with a London Junction as I suppose it will direct the discharge in the direction of flow as per the detail below. As you can see it does not involve much additional space as it is the last foot or two that is the 45. For old/in use clay pipes you can get a saddle connection (below) that does the same without having to break the whole pipe.


To answer your question, they are both pretty large pipes so should have decent flows in them and i doubt wastewater dropping in at90 will make little difference to 45 in the grand scheme of things

 

[LittleInch]

The issue is impact force on a fragile, brittle pipe.