Eng-Tips is the largest forum for Engineering Professionals on the Internet.

Members share and learn making Eng-Tips Forums the best source of engineering information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations dmapguru on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Possible bug: significant difference in integration point stresses and stress at element's centroid

Status
Not open for further replies.

coolFL

Mechanical
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
39
Location
US
Hello all, 

I did one elastic-plastic simulation using Abaqus/FEA. I used C3D20T (hexahedral quad) solid element which has 27 integration points and 20 nodes. For one of the element, the stress that I got at the centroid is completely different from the stresses that I got at the integration points. Can somebody please tell me how Abaqus determines stresses at the centroid of the element from its integration pt. values? For reference, stresses at the integration points and centroid of this element are as follows:

 It. pt. 1 :  2929.26 MPa
It. pt. 2  :  2899.97 MPa
It. pt. 3 : 2744.67 MPa
It. pt. 4 : 2959.99 MPa
It. pt. 5 : 2923.19 MPa
It. pt. 6 : 2892.74 MPa
It. pt. 7 : 3008.94 MPa
It. pt. 8: 2946.87 MPa
It. pt. 9 : 2914.68 MPa
It. pt. 10 : 2901 MPa
It. pt. 11 : 2622.9 MPa
It. pt. 12 : 2328.21 MPa
It. pt. 13 : 2928.13 MPa
It. pt. 14 : 2895.74 MPa
It. pt. 15 : 2553.81 MPa
It. pt. 16 : 2956.9 MPa
It. pt. 17 : 2919.5 MPa
It. pt. 18 : 2802.65 MPa
It. pt. 19 : 2593.25 MPa
It. pt. 20 : 2239.77 MPa
It. pt. 21 : 1997.29 MPa
It. pt. 22 : 2913.44 MPa
It. pt. 23 : 2534.04 MPa
It. pt. 24 : 2190.04 MPa
It. pt. 25 : 2947.21 MPa
It. pt. 26 : 2866.59 MPa
It. pt. 27 : 2427.03 MPa

At the centroid, stress is 3402.07 MPa

Thank you in advance, 

Nik

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top