Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Part/ Body mirror 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bhaveshn

Mechanical
May 23, 2007
72
How I can miiror part or body within file itself without making a copy?


 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Hi,

there is a Function for it on the toolbar just below
the pattern icon. See also SE -> Help -> Index -> Mirror

- Mirror Copy Feature Command
- Mirror Copy Command

dy
 
Both command you mentioned is for copying. I don't want to duplicate, but to move as mirrored part.

 
Hi,

sorry, I've overlooked that. Then you may try this

- put the part in an assembly
- Function Mirror
- select the plane to mirror about
- select the part

- within the window that pops up
- select Mirror in column 'Action' when not already
set

OK

Close the asm without save. Now you should have in the same
folder the original part is in a new one the name is suffixed
by '_mir'

dy
 
Thanks Don,

I haven't checked yet, but I got a another solution:

Insert part copy a construction body, mirror it and convert it to a base feature (right click menu on mirror feature)

 
there is option for mirror when inserting a part copy.

Thanks Don!!
 
Hi,

yup, that's also a solution. Downside: it's a part copy
in both cases without any history.
When you have a need for the two parts then with the first
solution (mirror copy) you have this option:

after mirroring the part you can then split the part
by using the 'Divide Function' which will create
2 parts which are related to one, the 'Master Part'

dy
 
Going off at a slight tangent here - I would avoid creating opposite hand parts with the insert part cop/mirror command unless you are absolutely certain that you will always require both parts.
For example - I'm working on a job at the moment where someone has created the mirrored version of a machine and some of the parts are mirrored part coppies. Unfortunately only the mirrored version is used in the machine (and only the mirrored version is drawn !), so when I come to modify the part I have to go back to it's original and modify that one -- GRRRRRRR!!!

bc.
 
Beachcomber,

Depending on how complex the part is, you could use the direct edit tools to make modifications of the part copy and leave the original as is. I've even started experimenting with using copies of an original part then stretching, adding holes and other featuers using direct edit to make longer parts etc. This seems to be a simpler approach than using families of parts.

Kyle
 
Hi Kyle,
Yes you're quite correct, and these are valid and extremely useful methods when applied correctly. It's just that in this case the original part was copied for the new project but was NEVER going to be used. Only the mirrored part is used.
Again going off the point slightly here, this particular customer creates an entirely new set of models and drawings for every project - and that's about 1000 drawings - even if they are identical to previous projects. Hard to believe really - but it's great for us contractors !!

bc
 
Beachcomber,

I just tried a mirrored part copy and SE won't let you break the link. I think the only solution is to use the mirrored part copy and maintain the link or export the mirrored part copy as a .sat, STEP, parasolid etc. Of course, now you have no history on the part.

On your second comment, do you use Rev manager to copy the drawings and models to save time. I did that when I made a new revision to drawings that also now needed to be linked to family of parts members and it worked perfectly.

Kyle
 
Kyle,
Yes we do copying with rev manager, property manager etc.

bc
 
kjoiner,

you can break the link. Once your part is copied, open or edit the mirrored part. Modify the part copy feature. Click on the change settings/parameters button in the SmartStep ribbon bar, and in the dialog box that opens, uncheck "link to file".

I have no idea why you can't do that while you're creating the part...

BTW my terms may not be all correct as I'm working on a French version...

 
Gemnoc,

I forgot to look in the settings dialogue box. I only right clicked and tried the break link. Then I tried interpart manager. I forgot the third way.

Kyle
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor